1 <!-- html-header type=current begin -->
8 <meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=edge,chrome=1">
12 <script>window.is_euro_union = 1;</script>
13 <script src="https://a.fsdn.com/con/js/sftheme/vendor/promise.polyfill.min.js"></script>
14 <script src="https://a.fsdn.com/con/js/sftheme/cmp.js"></script>
15 <script src="https://slashdot.org/country.js"></script>
16 <script type='text/javascript'>
17 if (window.is_euro_union) {
19 // to test: 'Display UI': 'always',
20 'Publisher Name': 'Slashdot',
21 'Publisher Logo': 'https://a.fsdn.com/sd/sdlogo.svg',
22 'Consent Scope': 'global group',
23 'Consent Scope Group URL': 'https://slashdot.org/gdpr-cookies.pl',
27 <link rel="stylesheet" href="//a.fsdn.com/con/css/sftheme/sandiego/cmp.css" type="text/css">
28 <style type="text/css">
29 .qc-cmp-publisher-logo, .qc-cmp-nav-bar-publisher-logo {
30 background-color: #016765;
34 if (!window.is_euro_union) {
35 (function (s,o,n,a,r,i,z,e) {s['StackSonarObject']=r;s[r]=s[r]||function(){
36 (s[r].q=s[r].q||[]).push(arguments)},s[r].l=1*new Date();i=o.createElement(n),
37 z=o.getElementsByTagName(n)[0];i.async=1;i.src=a;z.parentNode.insertBefore(i,z)
38 })(window,document,'script','https://www.stack-sonar.com/ping.js','stackSonar');
39 stackSonar('stack-connect', '66');
43 <script id="before-content" type="text/javascript">
45 if (typeof window.sdmedia !== 'object') {
48 if (typeof window.sdmedia.site !== 'object') {
49 window.sdmedia.site = {};
52 var site = window.sdmedia.site;
53 site.rootdir = "//slashdot.org";
57 pagemark: '82012362523388204',
58 before_content: (new Date).getTime()
60 function pageload_done( $, console, maybe ){
61 pageload.after_readycode = (new Date).getTime();
62 pageload.content_ready_time = pageload.content_ready - pageload.before_content;
63 pageload.script_ready_time = pageload.after_readycode - pageload.content_ready;
64 pageload.ready_time = pageload.after_readycode - pageload.before_content;
65 // Only report 1% of cases.
66 maybe || (Math.random()>0.01) || $.ajax({ data: {
68 pagemark: pageload.pagemark,
69 dom: pageload.content_ready_time,
70 js: pageload.script_ready_time
74 <meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=edge,chrome=1">
76 <title>'I've Seen the Future of Consumer AI, and it Doesn't Have One' - Slashdot</title>
77 <meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=utf-8">
79 <meta name="description" content="Andrew Orlowski of The Register recounts all the gadgets supercharged with AI that he came across at IFA tradeshow last week -- and wonders what value AI brought to the table. He writes: I didn't see a blockchain toothbrush at IFA in Berlin last week, but I'm sure there was one lurking about somewhe...">
81 <meta name="twitter:card" content="summary">
82 <meta name="twitter:site" content="@slashdot">
83 <meta name="twitter:domain" content="tech.slashdot.org">
84 <meta property="og:url" content="https://tech.slashdot.org/story/18/09/06/205221/ive-seen-the-future-of-consumer-ai-and-it-doesnt-have-one?utm_source=rss1.0mainlinkanon&utm_medium=feed">
86 <meta property="og:title" content="'I've Seen the Future of Consumer AI, and it Doesn't Have One' - Slashdot">
87 <meta property="og:description" content="Andrew Orlowski of The Register recounts all the gadgets supercharged with AI that he came across at IFA tradeshow last week -- and wonders what value AI brought to the table. He writes: I didn't see a blockchain toothbrush at IFA in Berlin last week, but I'm sure there was one lurking about somewhe...">
91 <meta property="og:image" content="https://a.fsdn.com/sd/topics/ai_64.png">
93 <meta property="fb:admins" content="100000696822412">
94 <meta property="fb:page_id" content="267995220856">
96 <meta name="viewport" content="width=1000, user-scalable=yes, minimum-scale=0, maximum-scale=10.0" />
97 <meta name="apple-mobile-web-app-capable" content="yes">
98 <meta name="apple-mobile-web-app-status-bar-style" content="black">
100 <link rel="canonical" href="https://tech.slashdot.org/story/18/09/06/205221/ive-seen-the-future-of-consumer-ai-and-it-doesnt-have-one">
102 <link rel="alternate" media="only screen and (max-width: 640px)" href="http://m.slashdot.org/story/345542" >
105 <link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" media="screen, projection" href="//a.fsdn.com/sd/classic.ssl.css?8f5016a67a2f2048" >
106 <!--[if IE 8]><link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" media="screen, projection" href="//a.fsdn.com/sd/ie8-classic.ssl.css?8f5016a67a2f2048" ><![endif]-->
107 <!--[if IE 7]><link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" media="screen, projection" href="//a.fsdn.com/sd/ie7-classic.ssl.css?8f5016a67a2f2048" ><![endif]-->
121 <!-- SMACKS: NEW CSS -->
122 <link rel="stylesheet" href="//a.fsdn.com/sd/css/app.css?8f5016a67a2f2048">
124 <script type='text/javascript'>
125 var _gaq = _gaq || [];
136 <script type="text/javascript" id="pbjs_script" data-dom="https://d3tglifpd8whs6.cloudfront.net" src="https://d3tglifpd8whs6.cloudfront.net/js/prebid/slash-story/slash-story.min.js"></script>
137 <script type='text/javascript'>
138 /*global performance */
139 var googletag = window.googletag || {};
140 googletag.cmd = googletag.cmd || [];
142 window.Ads_disallowPersonalization = 1;
143 bizx.cmp.ifConsent('all', 'all', function(){
144 window.Ads_disallowPersonalization = 0;
146 window.Ads_disallowPersonalization = 1;
148 window.bizxPrebid.Ads.initPrebid(window.bizxPrebid.adUnits);
152 <!-- prep GPT ads -->
153 <script type='text/javascript'>
155 function page_type (loc) {
157 only four page types:
161 - Other (but AdOps wants 'Homepage' again)
163 var path = loc.pathname;
164 var just_the_root = /^\/?$/.test(path);
165 var story_or_poll = /^\/(story(?=\/)|submission(?=\/)|poll(?=\/|Booth|s\b))/i.exec(path);
167 var page_type = just_the_root ? 'homepage'
168 : story_or_poll ? story_or_poll[1]
172 if (page_type.toLowerCase() === 'submission')
173 page_type = 'story'; // submissions are like stories, right?
174 else if (page_type.toLowerCase() === 'other')
175 page_type = 'homepage'; // this one might move out of here
179 function page_section (loc) {
180 //var greek = ['alpha', 'beta', 'gamma', 'delta'].join('|');
181 //var hostwise = '^([a-z]+)(?:-(?:'+greek+'))?\\.(?:slashdot\\.org|\\.xb\\.sf\\.net)$';
182 var pathwise = '^/(?:(recent|popular|blog)|stories/([^/]+))';
183 var rootwise = '^\/?$';
185 //var hostwisely = new RegExp(hostwise,'i').exec(loc.hostname);
186 var pathwisely = new RegExp(pathwise,'i').exec(loc.pathname);
187 var rootwisely = new RegExp(rootwise,'i').exec(loc.pathname);
189 var section = (rootwisely && 'homepage')
190 || (pathwisely && (pathwisely[1] || pathwisely[2]))
194 return section.replace(/[^_a-z]/ig, '');
196 function single_size (size) {
197 return '' + size[0] + 'x' + size[1];
199 function sz_sz (sz) {
202 if (sz[0] instanceof Array) {
204 sizes.push(single_size(sz[size]));
206 return sizes.join(',');
208 return single_size(sz);
212 function unique_tpc_array(array1,array2) {
213 var j = array1.concat(array2);
214 j.forEach(function (v,i,a) {
215 a[i] = v.replace(/[^_a-z]/ig, '');
217 return j.filter(function (v,i,a) {
218 return v != '' && a.indexOf(v) === i;
224 - 'npt' = "no page type" in ad unit name
227 '728x90_A': { 'sz': [[728, 90], [970, 90], [970, 250], [980, 66]] },
228 '728x90_B': { 'sz': [728, 90] },
229 '728x90_C': { 'sz': [728, 90], 'skip': { 'homepage': 1 } },
230 'HubIcon_200x90_A': { 'sz': [[200, 90], [220, 90]]},
231 'PowerSwitch_980x66_A': { 'sz': [980, 66], 'skip': { 'homepage': 1 } },
232 'PollPeel': { 'sz': [200, 90], 'skip': { 'homepage': 1 } },
233 //'VideoWidget_300x250': { 'sz': [300, 250], 'npt': 1 },
234 '300x250_A': { 'sz': [[300, 250], [300, 600], [300, 1050]] },
235 '300x250_B': { 'sz': [[300, 250], [300, 600]] },
236 '300x250_C': { 'sz': [[300, 250], [300, 600]] },
237 '300x250_D': { 'sz': [[300, 250], [300, 600]] },
238 'Pulse_300x600_A': { 'sz': [300, 600] },
239 //'Polls_Detail_300x250_A': { 'sz': [[300, 250], [300, 600]], 'npt': 1 },
240 //'Poll_300x250_A': { 'sz': [[300, 250], [300, 600]], 'npt': 1 },
241 //'SD_Story_1x1': { 'sz': [1, 1] },
242 '1x1': { 'sz': [1, 1] }
245 //var network_path = '/41014381/Slashdot/';
246 var network_path = '/41014381/Slashdot/';
247 var tag_name_prefix = 'SD';
248 var tag_name_linkage = '_';
249 var tag_name_pagetype = page_type(location);
250 var tag_topic = page_section(location);
251 if(tag_name_pagetype == 'poll'){
252 tag_name_pagetype = 'Poll';
254 var before_tag_pagetyped = network_path
260 var before_tag_pagetypeless = network_path
263 /* + tag_name_pagetype */
264 /* + tag_name_linkage */
268 googletag.cmd.push(function() {
270 function remove_sticky_top() {
271 setTimeout(function(){
272 $('#div-gpt-ad-728x90_a').parent('div').addClass('adwrap-viewed-banner');
273 $('#div-gpt-ad-728x90_a').addClass('viewableImpression');
276 function remove_sticky_railad() {
277 setTimeout(function(){
278 $('#slashboxes .adwrap-unviewed').addClass('adwrap-viewed-railad');
279 $('.railad').addClass('viewableImpression');
282 function viewable_imp (slot) {
284 if(typeof slot[i] !== 'string') continue;
286 case "/41014381/Slashdot/SD_homepage_728x90_A":
287 case "/41014381/Slashdot/SD_story_728x90_A":
288 case "/41014381/Slashdot/SD_Poll_728x90_A":
289 case "/41014381/Slashdot/SD_homepage_728x90_Ref_A":
290 case "/41014381/Slashdot/SD_story_728x90_Ref_A":
291 case "/41014381/Slashdot/SD_Poll_728x90_Ref_A":
294 case "/41014381/Slashdot/SD_homepage_300x250_A":
295 case "/41014381/Slashdot/SD_story_300x250_A":
296 case "/41014381/Slashdot/SD_Poll_300x250_A":
297 case "/41014381/Slashdot/SD_homepage_300x250_Ref_A":
298 case "/41014381/Slashdot/SD_story_300x250_Ref_A":
299 case "/41014381/Slashdot/SD_Poll_300x250_Ref_A":
300 remove_sticky_railad();
303 //if(slot[i] === "/41014381/Slashdot/SD_homepage_728x90_A") remove_sticky_top();
304 //if(slot[i] === "/41014381/Slashdot/SD_homepage_300x250_A") remove_sticky_railad();
307 function define_me_a_slot (tag) {
308 if (tags[tag].skip && tags[tag].skip[tag_name_pagetype])
310 var sandbox_regex = /\.xb\.sf\.net$/i;
311 var full_name = tags[tag].npt // "no page type"
312 ? before_tag_pagetypeless + tag
313 : before_tag_pagetyped + tag
315 var div_id = 'div-gpt-ad-' + tag.toLowerCase();
318 // extend jQuery and get URL query params
320 getQueryParameters : function(str) {
321 return (str || document.location.search).replace(/(^\?)/,'').split("&").map(function(n){
322 return n = n.split("="),this[n[0]] = n[1],this
327 var queryParams = $.getQueryParameters();
329 if( queryParams.source === 'autorefresh' ) {
330 full_name = full_name.replace(/(\d+x\d+)/,'$1_Ref');
331 //console.log('TAG NAME: ', full_name);
334 service = googletag.defineSlot(
338 ).addService(googletag.pubads());
340 service.setTargeting('sz', tags[tag].sz);
343 var frontend_tpc = tag_topic.split(",");
344 var backend_tpc = [ "technology", "ai", "gadget", "gadgets", "ifa" ];
346 var tpc_final = unique_tpc_array(frontend_tpc, backend_tpc);
347 service.setTargeting('tpc', tpc_final);
348 if (location.hostname.match(sandbox_regex)) {
349 service.setTargeting('test', 'adops');
355 define_me_a_slot(tag, false);
357 googletag.pubads().addEventListener('impressionViewable', function(event) {
358 viewable_imp(event.slot);
361 googletag.pubads().setTargeting('requestSource', 'GPT');
362 googletag.pubads().setRequestNonPersonalizedAds(window.Ads_disallowPersonalization);
363 googletag.pubads().enableAsyncRendering();
366 googletag.pubads().collapseEmptyDivs();
367 window.bizxPrebid.SAFEFRAMES = true;
368 bizxPrebid.Ads.pushToGoogle();
369 googletag.enableServices();
377 <script type="text/javascript"> try{(function(){ var cb = new Date().getTime(); var s = document.createElement("script"); s.defer = true; s.src = "//tag.crsspxl.com/s1.js?d=2397&cb="+cb; var s0 = document.getElementsByTagName('script')[0]; s0.parentNode.insertBefore(s, s0); })();}catch(e){} </script>
379 <!-- AdBlock Check -->
381 var isAdBlockActive = true;
383 <script async src="//a.fsdn.com/sd/js/scripts/ad.js?8f5016a67a2f2048"></script>
386 <body class="anon firehose ">
389 <script src="//a.fsdn.com/sd/all-minified.js?8f5016a67a2f2048" type="text/javascript"></script>
392 <script type="text/javascript">
394 var regexp=/\s*(?:\d+|many)\s+more\s*/i;
397 var auto_more_count = 1;
399 function auto_more(){
400 var $more_link = $('#more-experiment a');
401 $more_link.each(function(){
402 var $lastitem = $('#firehoselist>article.fhitem:visible:last');
403 if ( Bounds.intersect(window, $lastitem) ) {
406 !--auto_more_count && (auto_more=undefined);
407 // don't allow a call till the next paginate gets built and |more_possible|
408 $(document).unbind('scroll', call_auto_more);
413 function call_auto_more(){ auto_more && auto_more(); }
416 $('#more-experiment a').
417 live('more-possible', function( event ){
418 var $more_link=$(this);
419 if ( regexp.test($more_link.text()) ) {
421 $(document).bind('scroll', call_auto_more);
423 $(document).unbind('scroll', call_auto_more);
429 <!--[if lt IE 9]><script src="//a.fsdn.com/sd/html5.js"></script><![endif]-->
432 <script type="text/javascript">
434 if (typeof window.janrain !== 'object') window.janrain = {};
435 if (typeof window.janrain.settings !== 'object') window.janrain.settings = {};
437 /* _______________ can edit below this line _______________ */
439 janrain.settings.tokenUrl = 'https://slashdot.org/token_callback.pl';
440 janrain.settings.type = 'embed';
441 janrain.settings.appId = 'ggidemlconlmjciiohla';
442 janrain.settings.appUrl = 'https://login.slashdot.org';
443 janrain.settings.providers = [
448 janrain.settings.providersPerPage = '5';
449 janrain.settings.format = 'one column';
450 janrain.settings.actionText = 'Sign in with';
451 janrain.settings.showAttribution = false;
452 janrain.settings.fontColor = '#666666';
453 janrain.settings.fontFamily = 'lucida grande, Helvetica, Verdana, sans-serif';
454 janrain.settings.backgroundColor = '#ffffff';
455 janrain.settings.width = '300';
456 janrain.settings.borderColor = '#cccccc';
457 janrain.settings.borderRadius = '5'; janrain.settings.buttonBorderColor = '#CCCCCC';
458 janrain.settings.buttonBorderRadius = '0';
459 janrain.settings.buttonBackgroundStyle = 'gray';
460 janrain.settings.language = '';
461 janrain.settings.linkClass = 'janrainEngage';
463 /* _______________ can edit above this line _______________ */
465 function isReady() { janrain.ready = true; };
466 if (document.addEventListener) {
467 document.addEventListener("DOMContentLoaded", isReady, false);
469 window.attachEvent('onload', isReady);
472 var e = document.createElement('script');
473 e.type = 'text/javascript';
474 e.id = 'janrainAuthWidget';
476 e.src = 'https://rpxnow.com/js/lib/login.slashdot.org/engage.js';
478 var s = document.getElementsByTagName('script')[0];
479 s.parentNode.insertBefore(e, s);
483 <script src="//cdn-social.janrain.com/social/janrain-social.min.js"></script>
484 <script type="text/javascript">
487 janrain.settings.appUrl = "https://login.slashdot.org";
488 $twitter = $('body .janrain_twitterButton');
489 $twitter.append('<i class="icon-twitter"></i>');
491 janrain.settings.social = {
499 shareCountMin: "100",
500 shareCountMode: "combined"
505 <!-- index2_variant ||-->
508 <script type="text/javascript">
509 if (!window.is_euro_union) {
510 window._taboola = window._taboola || [];
511 _taboola.push({home:'auto'});
512 !function (e, f, u) {
515 f.parentNode.insertBefore(e, f);
516 }(document.createElement('script'),
517 document.getElementsByTagName('script')[0],
518 '//cdn.taboola.com/libtrc/slashdot/loader.js');
522 <!-- html-header type=current end --><!-- header type=current begin -->
526 <link rel="top" title="News for nerds, stuff that matters" href="//slashdot.org/" >
527 <link rel="search" title="Search Slashdot" href="//tech.slashdot.org/search.pl">
528 <link rel="alternate" title="Slashdot RSS" href="http://rss.slashdot.org/Slashdot/slashdotMain" type="application/rss+xml">
529 <link rel="shortcut icon" href="/favicon.ico" type="image/x-icon">
532 <div id="top_parent"></div>
533 <a name="topothepage"></a>
535 <div class="container">
536 <div class="nav-wrap">
537 <nav class="nav-primary" role="navigation" aria-label="Global Navigation">
539 <a href="//slashdot.org"><span>Slashdot</span></a>
542 <ul class="nav-site">
543 <li><a href="//slashdot.org"><i class="icon-book" title="Stories"></i><span>Stories</span></a></li>
545 <ul class="filter-firehose">
546 <li class="nav-label">Firehose <i class="icon-angle-right"></i></li>
547 <li><a href="//slashdot.org/recent">All</a></li>
548 <li><a href="//slashdot.org/popular">Popular</a></li>
551 <li><a href="//slashdot.org/polls"><i class="icon-chart-bar" title="Polls"></i><span>Polls</span></a></li>
554 <li><a href="//ask.slashdot.org"><i class="icon-question-circle"></i><span>Ask</span></a></li>
556 <li><a href="//events.slashdot.org"><i class="icon-calendar"></i><span>Events</span></a></li>
558 <li><a href="http://deals.slashdot.org/?utm_source=slashdot&utm_medium=navbar&utm_campaign=dealshp_1" target="_blank"><i class="sd-mini" title="Deals"></i> <span>Deals</span></a></li>
560 <a href="//slashdot.org/submission" class="btn btn-success">Submit</a>
562 <nav class="nav-user" role="navigation" aria-label="user access and account controls">
563 <form id="search" class="form-inline nav-search-form" method="get" action="//slashdot.org/index2.pl">
564 <!-- //tech.slashdot.org/index2.pl" -->
565 <div class="form-group">
566 <label class="sr-only" for="sitesearch">Search Slashdot</label>
567 <div class="input-group">
568 <input type="text" id="" class="" name="fhfilter" value="" placeholder="Search">
571 <button type="submit" class="btn icon-search"></button>
573 <ul class="user-access">
577 <a href="//slashdot.org/my/login" onclick="show_login_box(); return false;"><i class="icon-login"></i><span> Login</span></a>
583 <li class="nav-label">or</li>
588 <a href="//slashdot.org/my/newuser" ><i class="icon-user-add"></i><span> Sign up</span></a>
596 <div class="nav-secondary-wrap">
597 <nav class="nav-secondary" role="secondary-navigation">
599 <li class="nav-label">Topics: </li>
600 <li><a href="//devices.slashdot.org">Devices</a></li>
601 <li><a href="//build.slashdot.org">Build</a></li>
602 <li><a href="//entertainment.slashdot.org">Entertainment</a></li>
603 <li><a href="//technology.slashdot.org">Technology</a></li>
604 <li><a href="//slashdot.org/?fhfilter=opensource">Open Source</a></li>
605 <li><a href="//science.slashdot.org">Science</a></li>
606 <li><a href="//yro.slashdot.org">YRO</a></li>
607 <!-- <li><a href="//slashdot.org/topics.pl">more...</a></li> -->
610 <nav class="nav-social" role="social navigation">
612 <li class="nav-label">Follow us:</li>
613 <li><a href="http://rss.slashdot.org/Slashdot/slashdotMain" target="_blank"><i class="icon-rss-squared"></i><span class="sr-only">RSS</span></a></li>
614 <li><a href="http://www.facebook.com/slashdot" target="_blank"><i class="icon-facebook-squared"></i><span class="sr-only">Facebook</span></a></li>
615 <li><a href="https://plus.google.com/112601993642376762846/" target="_blank"><i class="icon-gplus-squared"></i><span class="sr-only">Google+</span></a></li>
616 <li><a href="http://twitter.com/slashdot" target="_blank"><i class="icon-twitter-squared"></i><span class="sr-only">Twitter</span></a></li>
617 <li><a href="//slashdot.org/newsletter" target="_blank"><i class="icon-mail-squared"></i><span class="sr-only">Newsletter</span></a></li>
625 <div class="message-bar" id="firehose-message-tray">
626 <span class="icon-quote-left"></span>
630 Follow Slashdot stories on <a href="http://twitter.com/slashdot">Twitter</a>
636 <div id='embbeded_login_modal' class="hide">
637 <form action="https://slashdot.org/my/login" method="post" onsubmit="if (global_returnto) { this.returnto.value = global_returnto }" class="embedded"><fieldset style="-webkit-border-radius:10px 10px 0 0;border-radius:10px 10px 0 0;-moz-border-radius:10px 10px 0 0">
638 <div style='height:25px;'> </div>
639 <input type="hidden" name="returnto" value="">
640 <input type="hidden" name="op" value="userlogin">
642 <label class="fleft" for="unickname">Nickname:</label>
643 <input type="text" name="unickname" value="">
646 <label class="fleft" for="upasswd">Password:</label>
647 <input type="password" name="upasswd" placeholder="6-1024 characters long">
649 <label class="checkbox"><input type="checkbox" name="login_temp" value="yes"> Public Terminal</label>
652 <input type="submit" name="userlogin" value="Log In" class="fno"> <a href="//slashdot.org/my/mailpassword" class="btn link" onclick="getModalPrefs('sendPasswdModal', 'Retrieve Password', 1); return false;">Forgot your password?</a>
655 <div id="janrainEngageEmbed"></div>
656 <div class="actions">
657 <a class="ico close" onclick="hide_login_slider();" href=""><span>Close</span></a>
662 <div class="banner-wrapper">
663 <div class="adwrap adwrap-unviewed banner-contain">
665 <div id='div-gpt-ad-728x90_a'><script type='text/javascript'>
666 googletag.cmd.push(function(){
667 googletag.display('div-gpt-ad-728x90_a');});</script></div>
668 <div id='div-gpt-ad-hubicon_200x90_a'><script type='text/javascript'>
669 googletag.cmd.push(function(){
670 googletag.display('div-gpt-ad-hubicon_200x90_a');});</script></div>
674 <a name="main-articles"></a>
676 <!-- header type=current end --><!-- body begin -->
686 <style type="text/css">
688 text-decoration:none;
697 menu[type=context]:not(.brief) {
698 background-color:#dfdfdf;
703 border-color:#eeeeee #aaaaaa #aaaaaa #eeeeee;
704 -moz-border-radius-topright:.7em;
705 -webkit-border-top-right-radius: 0.7em 0.7em;
708 menu.full[type=context] > a.slash-hover:first-child {
709 -moz-border-radius-topright:.6em;
710 -webkit-border-top-right-radius: 0.6em 0.6em;
715 menu.brief[type=context] > a {
716 -moz-border-radius:.6em;
717 -webkit-border-radius: 0.6em;
719 background-color:#000000;
723 span.briefmenu a.tag:not(.datatype) {
731 /* #tag-menu a, #feedback-menu a { */
732 menu.tag-menu-admin a {
739 margin:-0.1em -0.5em;
744 .tags .edit-bar { position:relative; }
745 article aside .share .addthis_toolbox { display:block; width:60px; float:left; }
746 article aside.view_mode .share { min-width:120px; padding-top:.5em; }
747 #firehose.list article header h2 {padding-left: 20px; !important}
748 .novote .vote { display:none; }
750 .vote > a, .votedup > a, .voteddown > a {
751 display:inline-block;
754 margin: 2px 10px 0 0;
755 color:rgb(255,255,255);
756 text-decoration:none;
763 border-color:rgba(0,0,0,0.5);
766 .vote > a, .votedup > a, .voteddown > a {color:rgb(0,0,0);}
768 article.fhitem-submission h2 .vote > a, article.fhitem-submission h2 .votedup > a, article.fhitem-submission h2 .voteddown > a { border-color:rgba(0,0,0,0.15); }
769 .vote .up, .vote .down, .votedup .up, .votedup .down, .voteddown .up, .voteddown .down { border-radius: 4px; -moz-border-radius: 4px; -webkit-border-radius: 4px; /* text-shadow:0 0 2px #000000; }*/}
770 article:not(.fhitem-story) .vote .up,article:not(.fhitem-story) .vote .down,article:not(.fhitem-story) .votedup .up,article:not(.fhitem-story) .votedup .down,article:not(.fhitem-story) .voteddown .up,article:not(.fhitem-story) .voteddown .down { /*text-shadow:none !important; */}
771 .voteddown .down, .votedup .up { margin-right: 10px; text-indent:2px; line-height:24px; }
772 article:not(.fhitem-story) .votedup .up,article:not(.fhitem-story) .voteddown .down {background: rgb(174,174,174);background-image: -webkit-gradient(linear, 0% 0%, 0% 100%, from(rgb(174,174,174)), to(rgb(193,193,193)));background-image: -moz-linear-gradient(100% 100% 90deg,rgb(193,193,193), rgb(174,174,174) 100%);color:rgb(0,0,0);}
773 article.fhitem-story .votedup .up,article.fhitem-story .voteddown .down {background: rgb(0,66,66);background-image: -webkit-gradient(linear, 0% 0%, 0% 100%, from(rgb(0,53,53)), to(rgb(0,102,102)));background-image: -moz-linear-gradient(100% 100% 90deg,rgb(0,102,102), rgb(0,53,53) 100%);}
778 #tag-menu span.var-tag {
783 menu.reasons-menu a {
784 padding:0 .25em 0 .25em;
786 -moz-border-radius:.5em;
787 -webkit-border-radius:.5em;
791 menu.reasons-menu a:hover {
792 background:rgb(153,153,153);
793 background:-moz-linear-gradient(100% 100% 90deg, rgb(102,102,102), rgb(153,153,153) 70%) repeat scroll 0 0 rgb(102,102,102);
794 background-image: -webkit-gradient(linear, 0% 0%, 0% 100%, from(rgb(153,153,153)), to(rgb(102,102,102)));
796 text-decoration:none;
800 article.fhitem-story menu.reasons-menu a:hover {
801 background:#002323 !important;
802 background:-moz-linear-gradient(100% 100% 90deg, #002323, #005353 70%) repeat scroll 0 0 #002323 !important;
803 background-image: -webkit-gradient(linear, 0% 0%, 0% 100%, from(#005353), to(#002323)) !important;
813 div.fhitem h3 menu.reasons-menu {
817 div.fhitem h3 menu.reasons-menu a.tag {
821 #tag-menu a.slash-hover,
822 #feedback-menu a.slash-hover,
824 .tag-display span.tag:hover,
825 .tag-display span.tag.trigger {
827 background-color:rgb(0, 85, 85);
830 #tag-menu a.slash-hover span.var-tag {
842 text-decoration:none;
845 -moz-border-radius:.6em 0 0 .6em;
846 -webkit-border-radius:.6em 0 0 .6em;
847 -o-border-radius:.6em 0 0 .6em;
848 border-radius:.6em 0 0 .6em;
849 color:#fff !important;
850 background:transparent !important;
854 background:rgb(153,153,153) !important;
855 background:-moz-linear-gradient(100% 100% 90deg, rgb(102,102,102), rgb(153,153,153) 70%) repeat scroll 0 0 rgb(102,102,102) !important;
856 background-image: -webkit-gradient(linear, 0% 0%, 0% 100%, from(rgb(153,153,153)), to(rgb(102,102,102))) !important;
861 <menu id="nix-reasons" style="display:none">
862 <a class="tag">binspam</a><a class="tag">dupe</a><a class="tag">notthebest</a><a class="tag">offtopic</a><a class="tag">slownewsday</a><a class="tag">stale</a><a class="tag">stupid</a>
864 <menu id="nod-reasons" style="display:none">
865 <a class="tag">fresh</a><a class="tag">funny</a><a class="tag">insightful</a><a class="tag">interesting</a><a class="tag">maybe</a>
867 <menu id="comment-nix-reasons" style="display:none">
868 <a class="tag">offtopic</a><a class="tag">flamebait</a><a class="tag">troll</a><a class="tag">redundant</a><a class="tag">overrated</a>
870 <menu id="comment-nod-reasons" style="display:none">
871 <a class="tag">insightful</a><a class="tag">interesting</a><a class="tag">informative</a><a class="tag">funny</a><a class="tag">underrated</a>
874 <menu id="tag-nod-reasons" style="display:none">
875 <a class="tag">descriptive</a>
877 <menu id="feedback-menu" class="tag-menu-admin" type="context">
878 <a class="tag">typo</a><a class="tag">dupe</a><a class="tag">error</a>
880 <menu id="tag-menu" class="tag-menu-admin none" type="context">
882 <!-- <a data-op="!" class="nix">!<span class="var-tag hide"></span></a>-->
886 <script type="text/javascript">
888 var $CURRENT_MENU, $TAG_MENU=$('#tag-menu'), NOTNOT=/^!!/, IE7=/^7\.0/, TAG_PREFIX=/^\/tag\//;
890 function get_tag_name( $tag ){
891 return ($tag.attr('href') || '').replace(TAG_PREFIX, '') || $tag.text().toLowerCase();
894 function trigger_menu( e, selector, $menu, menu_content ){
895 var $target=$(original_target(e, selector)), in_use=$target.is('.trigger');
896 if ( $CURRENT_MENU ) {
897 $CURRENT_MENU.menu('cancel', e);
898 $CURRENT_MENU = null;
902 menu_content && $menu.stop(true, true).hide().html(menu_content);
903 ($CURRENT_MENU=$menu).menu('context', e);
908 function open_menu( trigger, $menu ){
909 var $trigger=$(trigger), $fhitem=$trigger.closest('.fhitem');
910 $fhitem.length && user_intent('interest', $fhitem[0]);
912 $menu.appendTo(document.body).css({ opacity:0 }).show();
914 var right = $fhitem.offset().left + $fhitem.width(),
915 global = $trigger.offset(),
916 local = $menu.offsetParent().offset();
918 // Ugly IE position hack required:
919 $.browser.msie && IE7.test($.browser.version) && (local.top = 0);
921 // pin the menu (horizontally) on-screen
922 global.left = Math.min(global.left, right-$menu.width());
924 $trigger.addClass('trigger');
926 position: 'absolute',
927 top: global.top - local.top + $trigger.height(),
928 left: global.left - local.left,
933 function close_menu( trigger, $menu ){
935 $(trigger).removeClass('trigger');
936 ($CURRENT_MENU===$menu) && ($CURRENT_MENU=false);
939 /* T2 tag context-menu */
940 var $TAG_MENU=$('#tag-menu'), NOTNOT=/^!!/;
943 var user_is_admin = 0;
947 $('a[rel=tag]').live('mousedown',function(ea){
948 window.open(this.href);
952 $('.tag-bar .disagree').live('mousedown',function(ee){
953 var fhitem = $(original_target(ee)).closest('.fhitem')[0],
954 command = ('!' + $(original_target(ee)).attr("data-tag")).replace(NOTNOT, '');
955 try { Tags.submit(fhitem, command); } catch ( err ) { }
962 live('mousedown', function( e ){
968 live('click', function( e ){
970 var target = original_target(e),
971 tag = $(target).text();
979 cssNamespace: 'slash',
983 start: function( e, ui ){
984 var $tag = $(ui.trigger),
985 tag = get_tag_name($tag),
986 context = firehose_settings && firehose_settings.viewtitle;
988 // Insert the tagname into the menu items where needed.
989 $TAG_MENU.find('span.var-tag').text(tag);
990 $TAG_MENU.find('a.nix').attr('title','not ' + tag);
993 // non-admins may only delete their own tags
994 $TAG_MENU.find('a:[data-op="-"]').toggle($tag.is('.my'));
997 // *tagname* in *viewtitle*
998 $TAG_MENU.find('a:[data-op="="]').toggle(!!context);
999 context && $TAG_MENU.find('span.var-view').text(context);
1001 open_menu($tag, $TAG_MENU);
1004 select: function( e, ui ){
1005 var $tag = $(ui.trigger),
1006 tag = get_tag_name($tag),
1007 op = $(ui.select).attr('data-op'),
1011 // Global for positioning other things.
1012 $related_trigger = $tag;
1020 fhitem = $tag.closest('.fhitem')[0];
1021 command = (op + tag).replace(NOTNOT, '');
1022 try { Tags.submit(fhitem, command); } catch ( err ) { }
1027 stop: function( e, ui ){ close_menu(ui.trigger, $TAG_MENU); }
1033 /* T2 feedback context-menu */
1037 /* T2 datatype context-menu (admin-only) */
1049 <!-- SMACKS: BEGIN STORY CONTENT -->
1050 <div class="container">
1051 <!--SMACKS: BEGING CENTER COLUMN -->
1052 <div class="main-wrap has-rail-right">
1053 <div class="main-content">
1054 <div class="grid_24 a2 ">
1056 <div id="firehose" class="nothumbs">
1057 <div id="firehoselist" class="fhroot fleft grid_24">
1058 <div id="announcement">
1059 <div id="announcementText" style="display: none;"> <span class="headline">Migrate from GitHub to SourceForge quickly and easily with <strong><a href="https://sourceforge.net/p/forge/documentation/GitHub%20Importer/">this tool</a></strong>.</span> Check out all of SourceForge’s <strong><a href="https://sourceforge.net/blog/brief-history-sourceforge-look-to-future/">recent improvements.</a></strong></div>
1060 <a href="" class="btn-close" title="don't show me this again" onclick="closeAnnouncement(); return false;">×</a>
1064 <script type="text/javascript">
1066 if (!$.cookie('hide_sitenotice_36')) {
1067 $('#announcement').fadeIn(300);
1070 function closeAnnouncement() {
1071 $('#announcement').fadeOut(300);
1072 $.cookie('hide_sitenotice_36', 'true', { path: '/', domain: 'slashdot.org', expires: 1 });
1075 <article id="firehose-102639856" data-fhid="102639856" data-fhtype="story" class="fhitem fhitem-story article usermode thumbs grid_24">
1076 <span class="sd-info-block" style="display: none">
1077 <span class="sd-key-firehose-id">102639856</span>
1078 <span class="type">story</span>
1093 <span class="topic" id="topic-102639856">
1094 <a href="//tech.slashdot.org/index2.pl?fhfilter=ai" onclick="return addfhfilter('ai');">
1096 <img src="//a.fsdn.com/sd/topics/ai_64.png" width="64" height="64" alt="AI" title="AI">
1107 <a href="//tech.slashdot.org/index2.pl?fhfilter=technology" onclick="return addfhfilter('technology');">
1109 <img src="//a.fsdn.com/sd/topics/technology_64.png" width="64" height="64" alt="Technology" title="Technology">
1129 <span id="title-102639856" class="story-title"> <a href="//tech.slashdot.org/story/18/09/06/205221/ive-seen-the-future-of-consumer-ai-and-it-doesnt-have-one">'I've Seen the Future of Consumer AI, and it Doesn't Have One'</a> <span class=" no extlnk"><a class="story-sourcelnk" href="https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/09/05/consumer_ai_ifa_2018_roundup/" title="External link - https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/09/05/consumer_ai_ifa_2018_roundup/" target="_blank"> (theregister.co.uk) </a></span></span>
1133 <!--<span class="comments commentcnt-102639856" >97</span>-->
1137 <!-- comment bubble -->
1139 <span class="comment-bubble"><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/story/18/09/06/205221/ive-seen-the-future-of-consumer-ai-and-it-doesnt-have-one#comments" title="">97</a></span>
1142 <div class="details" id="details-102639856">
1143 <span class="story-details">
1144 <span class="story-views">
1145 <span class="sodify" onclick="firehose_set_options('color', 'red')" title="Filter Firehose to entries rated red or better"></span><span class="icon-beaker pop1 " alt="Popularity" title="Filter Firehose to entries rated red or better" onclick="firehose_set_options('color', 'red')"><span></span></span>
1148 <span class="story-byline">
1163 <time id="fhtime-102639856" datetime="on Thursday September 06, 2018 @04:40PM">on Thursday September 06, 2018 @04:40PM</time>
1166 from the <span class="dept-text">there-is-no-spoon</span> dept.
1172 <div class="body" id="fhbody-102639856">
1179 <div id="text-102639856" class="p">
1182 Andrew Orlowski of <em>The Register</em> recounts all the gadgets <a href="https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/09/05/consumer_ai_ifa_2018_roundup/">supercharged with AI that he came across at IFA tradeshow last week -- and wonders what value AI brought to the table</a>. He writes:<i> I didn't see a blockchain toothbrush at IFA in Berlin last week, but I'm sure there was one lurking about somewhere. With 30 vast halls to cover, I didn't look too hard for it. But I did see many things almost as tragic that no one could miss -- AI being squeezed into almost every conceivable bit of consumer electronics. But none were convincing. If ever there was a solution looking for a problem, it's ramming AI into gadgets to show of a company's machine learning prowess. For the consumer it adds unreliability, cost and complexity, and the annoyance of being prompted. <br> <br> [...] Back to LG, which takes 2018's prize for sticking AI into a superfluous gadget. The centrepiece of its AI efforts this year is a robot, ClOi. Put Google Assistant or Alexa on wheels, and you have ClOi. I asked the booth person what exactly ClOi could do to be told "it can take notes for your shopping list." Why wasn't this miracle of the Fourth Industrial Revolution let loose on the LG floor? I wondered -- a question answered by this account of ClOi's debut at CES in January. Clearly things haven't improved much -- this robot buddy was kept indoors.</i><br>
1194 <aside class="grid_24 view_mode">
1196 <div class="units-12 story-detail-tags">
1197 <span id="sharethis-102639856" class="">
1204 <div class="story-controls">
1206 class="janrainSocialPlaceholder"
1207 data-janrain-url="https://tech.slashdot.org/story/18/09/06/205221/ive-seen-the-future-of-consumer-ai-and-it-doesnt-have-one"
1208 data-janrain-title="'I've Seen the Future of Consumer AI, and it Doesn't Have One'"
1209 data-janrain-message="'I've Seen the Future of Consumer AI, and it Doesn't Have One' @slashdot"
1216 <div class="story-tags">
1217 <div class="tright tw">
1219 <span class="tright tags">
1221 <menu type="toolbar" class="edit-bar">
1222 <span id="tagbar-102639856" class="tag-bar none">
1223 <a class="topic tag" rel="statictag" href="//slashdot.org/tag/" target="_blank"></a>
1224 <a class="popular tag" rel="statictag" href="//slashdot.org/tag/technology" target="_blank">technology</a>
1225 <a class="popular tag" rel="statictag" href="//slashdot.org/tag/ai" target="_blank">ai</a>
1226 <a class="popular tag" rel="statictag" href="//slashdot.org/tag/gadget" target="_blank">gadget</a>
1230 <a class="edit-toggle" href="/my/login/" onclick="show_login_box();return false;">
1231 <span class="icon-tag btn collapse"></span>
1235 <div class="tag-menu">
1236 <input class="tag-entry default" type="text" value="apply tags">
1256 <section class="grid_24" id="newa2footerv2">
1257 <div class="grid_6 pr">
1258 <h3><a title="Previous story" href="//tech.slashdot.org/story/18/09/06/1954253/400000-websites-vulnerable-through-exposed-git-directories?sdsrc=prev">←</a></h3>
1260 <div class="grid_12 rl">
1261 <h3>You may like to read:</h3>
1263 <div class="grid_6 ns">
1264 <h3><a title="Next story" href="//news.slashdot.org/story/18/09/06/1558206/computer-chips-are-still-made-in-usa?sdsrc=next">→</a></h3>
1266 <div class="grid_6">
1268 <a href="//tech.slashdot.org/story/18/09/06/1954253/400000-websites-vulnerable-through-exposed-git-directories?sdsrc=prev">400,000 Websites Vulnerable Through Exposed<nobr> <wbr></nobr>.git Directories </a>
1271 <div class="grid_12">
1279 <h2><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/story/18/01/08/1954203/james-damore-sues-google-for-allegedly-discriminating-against-conservative-white-men?sdsrc=popbyskid">James Damore Sues Google For Allegedly Discriminating Against Conservative White Men</a><br></h2>
1280 <h2><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/story/18/03/19/1736231/self-driving-uber-car-kills-arizona-woman-in-first-fatal-crash-involving-pedestrian?sdsrc=popbyskid">Self-Driving Uber Car Kills Arizona Woman in First Fatal Crash Involving Pedestrian</a><br></h2>
1281 <h2><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/story/17/11/16/0050243/twitter-bans-removes-verified-status-of-white-supremacists?sdsrc=popbyskid">Twitter Bans, Removes Verified Status of White Supremacists</a><br></h2>
1282 <h2><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/story/18/02/15/2255242/pro-gun-russian-bots-flood-twitter-after-parkland-shooting?sdsrc=popbyskid">Pro-Gun Russian Bots Flood Twitter After Parkland Shooting</a><br></h2>
1283 <h2><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/story/17/11/19/043243/i-see-things-differently-james-damore-on-his-autism-and-the-google-memo?sdsrc=popbyskid">'I See Things Differently': James Damore on his Autism and the Google Memo</a><br></h2>
1289 <div class="grid_6">
1292 <a href="//news.slashdot.org/story/18/09/06/1558206/computer-chips-are-still-made-in-usa?sdsrc=next">Computer Chips Are Still 'Made in USA'</a>
1310 <!-- SMACKS: BEGIN RIGHT RAIL -->
1311 <aside id="slashboxes" class="rail-right">
1313 <div id="slashboxesin" class="yui-b">
1318 <div class="railad adwrap-unviewed">
1319 <div id='div-gpt-ad-300x250_a'><script type='text/javascript'>
1320 googletag.cmd.push(function(){
1321 googletag.display('div-gpt-ad-300x250_a');});</script></div>
1323 <div id="taboola-below-article-thumbnails"></div>
1324 <script type="text/javascript">
1325 if ( isAdBlockActive) {
1326 window._taboola = window._taboola || [];
1328 mode: 'thumbnails-rr2',
1329 container: 'taboola-below-article-thumbnails',
1330 placement: 'Below Article Thumbnails',
1337 <!-- SMACKS: END RIGHT RAIL -->
1339 <!-- END STORY CONTENT -->
1341 <!-- THIS IS THE LOCATION FOR THE NEW STORY_B CODE -->
1342 <div class="adwrap">
1343 <div id='div-gpt-ad-728x90_b'><script type='text/javascript'>
1344 googletag.cmd.push(function(){
1345 googletag.display('div-gpt-ad-728x90_b');});</script></div>
1347 <div id="stackcommerce-adwrap" style="display:none;">
1348 <div style="margin:auto;max-width:970px;max-height:250px;">
1349 <div data-sc-widget data-publisher-id="66" data-categories="88,90" data-items-per-page="4" data-col-count="4" data-utm-source="slashdot.org" data-utm-content="story-deal-feed"></div>
1352 <script type="text/javascript">
1353 if (!window.is_euro_union) {
1354 if (isAdBlockActive) {
1356 url: '/ajax.pl?op=nel',
1357 success: function(html){
1359 $('#firehoselist article').eq(0).after(html);
1362 var stackCommerceDiv = document.getElementById('stackcommerce-adwrap');
1363 stackCommerceDiv.style = '';
1364 var stackCommerce = document.createElement('script');
1365 stackCommerce.async = true;
1366 stackCommerce.type = 'text/javascript';
1367 stackCommerce.src = 'https://widgets.stackcommerce.com/js-deal-feed/0.1/widget.js';
1368 var node = document.getElementsByTagName('script')[0];
1369 node.parentNode.insertBefore(stackCommerce, node);
1377 <!--------------------------->
1380 <!-- SMACKS: BEGIN COMMENTS CONTAINER -->
1381 <div class="container">
1382 <!-- SMACKS: BEGIN COMMENTS SECTION -->
1383 <div class="main-wrap">
1384 <div class="main-content">
1385 <div id="comments" class="a2commentwrap">
1387 <a name="comments"></a>
1388 <div id="comments" class="container">
1389 <div class="main-wrap">
1390 <div class="main-content">
1391 <section class="d2incommentspl">
1392 <div class="commentwrap" id="commentwrap">
1394 <div class="commentBox">
1395 <div class="title hide">
1398 <span class="escape-link"><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/story/18/09/06/205221/ive-seen-the-future-of-consumer-ai-and-it-doesnt-have-one" title="Back to Article - 'I've Seen the Future of Consumer AI, and it Doesn't Have One'">'I've Seen the Future of Consumer AI, and it Doesn't Have One'</a></span>
1400 <span class="commentBoxLinks"><a href="#" onclick="D2.ajaxFetchComments(0,1); return false"><span id="more_comments_num_d"></span> More</a>
1404 | <span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&op=reply&threshold=1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=" onclick="D2.replyTo(0); return false;">Reply</a>
1407 <a class="login" href="//tech.slashdot.org/login.pl" onclick="show_login_box(); return false">Login</a></span>
1413 <section class="grid_24" id="d2header"><div>
1415 <h2 class="commentspl test"><a title="Back to Article - 'I've Seen the Future of Consumer AI, and it Doesn't Have One'" href="//tech.slashdot.org/story/18/09/06/205221/ive-seen-the-future-of-consumer-ai-and-it-doesnt-have-one">'I've Seen the Future of Consumer AI, and it Doesn't Have One'</a></h2>
1417 <nav class="grid_24">
1418 <div class="grid_14 widthauto">
1420 <span class="ind"></span><a class="btn first" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&op=reply&threshold=1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=" onclick="D2.replyTo(0); return false;">Post</a>
1422 <!-- <a href="//tech.slashdot.org/search.pl?op=comments&sid=12580424" class="btn">Search <span class="totalcommentcnt">97</span> Comments</a> -->
1425 <a href="#" onclick="D2.ajaxFetchComments(0,1,'','',-1); return false" class="btn" id="d2loadall">Load All Comments</a>
1430 <div class="grid_10 d1or2">
1434 <div id="d2out" class="horizontal rooted grid_15">
1435 <div id="d2act" class="hide">
1436 <div class="loki" id="gods">
1437 <script type="text/javascript">
1439 D2.slider = new D2.Slider(
1440 D2.user_threshold(),
1441 D2.user_highlightthresh(),
1446 <div id="bones" class="grid_12">
1447 <div class="ccw-count-container grid_24">
1448 <span id="ccw-full-count-text" class="grid_8 ccw-count-text tcenter"><span></span><span id="ccw-full-phrase"> Full</span></span>
1449 <span id="ccw-abbr-count-text" class="grid_8 ccw-count-text"><span></span><span id="ccw-abbr-phrase"> Abbreviated</span></span>
1450 <span id="ccw-hide-count-text" class="grid_8 ccw-count-text tleft"><span></span><span id="ccw-hide-phrase"> Hidden</span></span>
1453 <div id="ccw-body" class="ccw-core">
1454 <div id="ccw-panel-container" class="ccw-core">
1455 <div id="ccw-full-panel" class="ccw-panel">
1456 /Sea<div class="ccw-panel-border"></div>
1457 <div id="ccw-full-count-pos" class="ccw-core-pos ccw-count-pos"></div>
1459 <div id="ccw-abbr-panel" class="ccw-panel">
1460 <div class="ccw-panel-border"></div>
1461 <div id="ccw-abbr-count-pos" class="ccw-core-pos ccw-count-pos"></div>
1463 <div id="ccw-hide-panel" class="ccw-panel">
1464 <div id="ccw-hide-count-pos" class="ccw-core-pos ccw-count-pos"></div>
1467 <div id="ccw-control" class="ccw-core">
1468 <div id="ccw-centering-rail" class="ccw-core">
1469 <div id="ccw-hide-bar-pos" class="ccw-core-pos">
1470 <div id="ccw-hide-bar" class="ccw-bar">
1471 <div id="ccw-hide-bar-tab" class="ccw-bar-tab"></div>
1472 <div class="ccwa"></div>
1473 <div class="ccwb"></div>
1474 <div id="ccw-hide-bar-upzone" class="ccw-upzone" onclick="D2.slider.stepTHT(HIDE_BAR, +1)"></div>
1475 <div id="ccw-hide-bar-downzone" class="ccw-downzone" onclick="D2.slider.stepTHT(HIDE_BAR, -1)"></div>
1478 <div id="ccw-abbr-bar-pos" class="ccw-core-pos">
1479 <div id="ccw-abbr-bar" class="ccw-bar">
1480 <div id="ccw-abbr-bar-tab" class="ccw-bar-tab"></div>
1481 <div class="ccwa"></div>
1482 <div class="ccwb"></div>
1483 <div id="ccw-abbr-bar-upzone" class="ccw-upzone" onclick="D2.slider.stepTHT(ABBR_BAR, +1)"></div>
1484 <div id="ccw-abbr-bar-downzone" class="ccw-downzone" onclick="D2.slider.stepTHT(ABBR_BAR, -1)"></div>
1490 <div class="ccw-score-label grid_24">
1491 <div class="grid_3"><span class="sc">Score:</span></div>
1492 <div class="grid_3">5<span class="lg"></span></div>
1493 <div class="grid_3">4<span class="lg"></span></div>
1494 <div class="grid_3">3<span class="lg"></span></div>
1495 <div class="grid_3">2<span class="lg"></span></div>
1496 <div class="grid_3">1<span class="lg"></span></div>
1497 <div class="grid_3">0<span class="lg"></span></div>
1498 <div class="grid_3">-1<span class="lg"></span></div>
1502 <div class="commentControlFooter">
1503 <a href="#" onclick="D2.ajaxFetchComments(0,1); return false"><span id="more_comments_num_c"></span> More</a>
1507 | <span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&op=reply&threshold=1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=" onclick="D2.replyTo(0); return false;">Reply</a>
1510 <a class="login" href="//tech.slashdot.org/login.pl" onclick="show_login_box(); return false">Login</a><div id="login_cover" class="hide" onclick="hide_login_box()"></div>
1511 <div id="login_box" class="hide">
1512 <div id="login_box_content">
1513 <div id='embbeded_login_modal' class="hide">
1514 <form action="https://slashdot.org/my/login" method="post" onsubmit="if (global_returnto) { this.returnto.value = global_returnto }" class="embedded"><fieldset style="-webkit-border-radius:10px 10px 0 0;border-radius:10px 10px 0 0;-moz-border-radius:10px 10px 0 0">
1515 <div style='height:25px;'> </div>
1516 <input type="hidden" name="returnto" value="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424">
1517 <input type="hidden" name="op" value="userlogin">
1519 <label class="fleft" for="unickname">Nickname:</label>
1520 <input type="text" name="unickname" value="">
1523 <label class="fleft" for="upasswd">Password:</label>
1524 <input type="password" name="upasswd" placeholder="6-1024 characters long">
1526 <label class="checkbox"><input type="checkbox" name="login_temp" value="yes"> Public Terminal</label>
1529 <input type="submit" name="userlogin" value="Log In" class="fno"> <a href="//slashdot.org/my/mailpassword" class="btn link" onclick="getModalPrefs('sendPasswdModal', 'Retrieve Password', 1); return false;">Forgot your password?</a>
1532 <div id="janrainEngageEmbed"></div>
1533 <div class="actions">
1534 <a class="ico close" onclick="hide_login_slider();" href=""><span>Close</span></a>
1537 <div class="actions">
1538 <a class="ico close" href="#" onclick="hide_login_box(); return false"><span>Close</span></a>
1542 <script type="text/javascript">logged_in = 0</script>
1544 <div id="commentControlBoxStatus" class="hide"></div>
1550 <a href="//tech.slashdot.org/search.pl?op=comments&sid=12580424" class="ui-icon search_comments">Search <span class="totalcommentcnt">97</span> Comments</a>
1552 <a class="pref ui-icon-w" href="//tech.slashdot.org/users.pl" onclick="show_login_box(); $('#modal_box').addClass('login'); return false;">Log In/Create an Account</a>
1556 <section id="besttabs" class="grid_24">
1557 <span class="legend">Comments Filter:</span>
1558 <ul class="besttabslist">
1560 <a href="#" data-filter-url="//tech.slashdot.org/story/18/09/06/205221/ive-seen-the-future-of-consumer-ai-and-it-doesnt-have-one#comments">All</a>
1564 <a href="" data-filter-url="//tech.slashdot.org/story/18/09/06/205221/ive-seen-the-future-of-consumer-ai-and-it-doesnt-have-one/insightful-comments#comments">Insightful</a>
1568 <a href="" data-filter-url="//tech.slashdot.org/story/18/09/06/205221/ive-seen-the-future-of-consumer-ai-and-it-doesnt-have-one/informative-comments#comments">Informative</a>
1572 <a href="" data-filter-url="//tech.slashdot.org/story/18/09/06/205221/ive-seen-the-future-of-consumer-ai-and-it-doesnt-have-one/interesting-comments#comments">Interesting</a>
1576 <a href="" data-filter-url="//tech.slashdot.org/story/18/09/06/205221/ive-seen-the-future-of-consumer-ai-and-it-doesnt-have-one/funny-comments#comments">Funny</a>
1582 $('#besttabs').show();
1583 $('.besttabslist').on('click', 'li a', function(e){
1585 var url = $(this).data('filter-url');
1586 //console.log('URL= ', url);
1588 .closest('ul').find('li').removeClass('active')
1590 .closest('li').addClass('active');
1591 window.location = url;
1596 <aside class="grid_24">
1598 <small><strong>The Fine Print:</strong> The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.</small>
1605 </div><script src="//a.fsdn.com/sd/comments-minified.js?8f5016a67a2f2048" type="text/javascript"></script>
1608 <script type="text/javascript">
1610 D2.d2_keybindings_disable()[191] = 1;
1612 D2.comments({ 57266016: { uid: 666, pid: 0, read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ 57266138, 57266386 ], opid: 0 }, 57266706: { uid: 589899, pid: 57265996, subject: "Re:AI in a Toaster!", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57265996 }, 57267460: { uid: 739463, pid: 57266566, subject: "Re:Stupid industry fads", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57266566 }, 57266226: { uid: 666, pid: 57265934, subject: "Re:Stupid industry fads", read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ ], opid: 57265934 }, 57267478: { uid: 739463, pid: 57266662, subject: "Re:Stupid industry fads", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57266662 }, 57267214: { uid: 3678879, pid: 57266716, subject: "Re:Stupid industry fads", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57266716 }, 57267484: { uid: 1102107, pid: 57266222, subject: "Re:Getting concerned myself", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57266222 }, 57266382: { uid: 666, pid: 57265934, subject: "Re:Stupid industry fads", read: 0, points: -1, kids: [ ], opid: 57265934 }, 57267042: { uid: 1066850, pid: 0, read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 0 }, 57267392: { uid: 2538182, pid: 57266452, subject: "Re:Nobody buys something because of AI", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57266452 }, 57266030: { uid: 666, pid: 0, read: 0, points: 1, kids: [ ], opid: 0 }, 57267474: { uid: 1102107, pid: 57266410, subject: "Re:OP must be joking...", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57266410 }, 57265994: { uid: 2481624, pid: 57265934, subject: "Re:Stupid industry fads", read: 0, points: 1, kids: [ 57267522 ], opid: 57265934 }, 57266562: { uid: 864189, pid: 0, read: 0, points: 1, kids: [ ], opid: 0 }, 57266590: { uid: 4662797, pid: 0, read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 0 }, 57266756: { uid: 666, pid: 57266038, subject: "Re:OP must be joking...", read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ 57267132 ], opid: 57266038 }, 57266782: { uid: 666, pid: 0, read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ ], opid: 0 }, 57266214: { uid: 188457, pid: 0, read: 0, points: 1, kids: [ 57266712 ], opid: 0 }, 57266928: { uid: 666, pid: 0, read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ ], opid: 0 }, 57267112: { uid: 874519, pid: 57266434, subject: "Re:OP must be joking...", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57266434 }, 57266114: { uid: 3678879, pid: 57265988, subject: "Re:Stupid industry fads", read: 0, points: 4, kids: [ 57266716 ], opid: 57265988 }, 57267442: { uid: 739463, pid: 57266462, subject: "Re:Now With AI!", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57266462 }, 57265956: { uid: 664417, pid: 0, read: 0, points: 4, kids: [ 57266044, 57266060, 57266374 ], opid: 0 }, 57266188: { uid: 2522392, pid: 57265938, subject: "Re:Journalists Always Get It Wrong", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ 57266582 ], opid: 57265938 }, 57266386: { uid: 2968043, pid: 57266016, subject: "Re:More dumb shit ...", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57266016 }, 57266150: { uid: 4891515, pid: 0, read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ 57266220, 57266402 ], opid: 0 }, 57266692: { uid: 589899, pid: 57266022, subject: "Re:Stupid industry fads", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57266022 }, 57267632: { uid: 472289, pid: 57266038, subject: "Re:OP must be joking...", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57266038 }, 57266452: { uid: 973549, pid: 0, read: 0, points: 3, kids: [ 57267392 ], opid: 0 }, 57266460: { uid: 666, pid: 57265996, subject: "Re:AI in a Toaster!", read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ ], opid: 57265996 }, 57265944: { uid: 666, pid: 0, read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ 57266018, 57266100 ], opid: 0 }, 57266100: { uid: 31985, pid: 57265944, subject: "Re:Now With AI!", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ 57266268 ], opid: 57265944 }, 57266410: { uid: 150076, pid: 57266038, subject: "Re:OP must be joking...", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ 57266524, 57267474 ], opid: 57266038 }, 57267570: { uid: 241799, pid: 0, read: 0, points: 1, kids: [ ], opid: 0 }, 57266390: { uid: 739463, pid: 57266238, subject: "Re:Now With AI!", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57266238 }, 57265988: { uid: 739463, pid: 57265934, subject: "Re:Stupid industry fads", read: 0, points: 5, kids: [ 57266056, 57266114, 57266182, 57266236, 57266348, 57266566, 57266662 ], opid: 57265934 }, 57266298: { uid: 666, pid: 57265996, read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ ], opid: 57265996 }, 57266376: { uid: 666, pid: 57266220, subject: "Re:I remember a time...", read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ ], opid: 57266220 }, 57266056: { uid: 874524, pid: 57265988, subject: "Re:Stupid industry fads", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57265988 }, 57266018: { uid: 739463, pid: 57265944, subject: "Re:Now With AI!", read: 0, points: 5, kids: [ 57266132, 57266238, 57266462, 57267462 ], opid: 57265944 }, 57266716: { uid: 37846, pid: 57266114, subject: "Re:Stupid industry fads", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ 57267214 ], opid: 57266114 }, 57267706: { uid: 666, pid: 57266038, read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ ], opid: 57266038 }, 57266370: { uid: 666, pid: 0, read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ ], opid: 0 }, 57267434: { uid: 2538182, pid: 57265934, subject: "Re:Stupid industry fads", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57265934 }, 57267490: { uid: 1102107, pid: 57266402, subject: "Re:I remember a time...", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57266402 }, 57266066: { uid: 666, pid: 0, read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ ], opid: 0 }, 57265970: { uid: 15797, pid: 0, read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ 57265996 ], opid: 0 }, 57266132: { uid: 3678879, pid: 57266018, subject: "Re:Now With AI!", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57266018 }, 57266222: { uid: 121541, pid: 57266136, subject: "Re:Getting concerned myself", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ 57267484 ], opid: 57266136 }, 57267056: { uid: 874519, pid: 57266506, subject: "Re:OP must be joking...", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57266506 }, 57267508: { uid: 666, pid: 57266126, subject: "Re:Stupid industry fads", read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ ], opid: 57266126 }, 57267662: { uid: 666, pid: 57267132, subject: "Re:OP must be joking...", read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ ], opid: 57267132 }, 57265890: { uid: 666, pid: 0, read: 0, points: -1, kids: [ ], opid: 0 }, 57266524: { uid: 874519, pid: 57266410, subject: "Re:OP must be joking...", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57266410 }, 57265934: { uid: 822350, pid: 0, read: 0, points: 5, kids: [ 57265952, 57265988, 57265994, 57266022, 57266126, 57266226, 57266382, 57266458, 57267434, 57267440 ], opid: 0 }, 57266402: { uid: 666, pid: 57266150, subject: "Re:I remember a time...", read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ 57267490 ], opid: 57266150 }, 57266236: { uid: 5013587, pid: 57265988, subject: "Re:Stupid industry fads", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57265988 }, 57266526: { uid: 666, pid: 57266136, subject: "Re:Getting concerned myself", read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ 57266808 ], opid: 57266136 }, 57266392: { uid: 666, pid: 57266268, subject: "Re: Now With AI!", read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ ], opid: 57266268 }, 57266182: { uid: 666, pid: 57265988, subject: "Re:Stupid industry fads", read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ ], opid: 57265988 }, 57266662: { uid: 666, pid: 57265988, subject: "Re:Stupid industry fads", read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ 57267478 ], opid: 57265988 }, 57267440: { uid: 672255, pid: 57265934, subject: "Re:Stupid industry fads", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57265934 }, 57266712: { uid: 589899, pid: 57266214, subject: "Re:I heard...", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57266214 }, 57266808: { uid: 921315, pid: 57266526, subject: "Re:Getting concerned myself", read: 0, points: 3, kids: [ ], opid: 57266526 }, 57266506: { uid: 892839, pid: 57266038, subject: "Re:OP must be joking...", read: 0, points: 1, kids: [ 57267056 ], opid: 57266038 }, 57267522: { uid: 666, pid: 57265994, read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ ], opid: 57265994 }, 57266490: { uid: 666, pid: 57265996, read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ ], opid: 57265996 }, 57266138: { uid: 666, pid: 57266016, read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ ], opid: 57266016 }, 57266042: { uid: 666, pid: 57265996, subject: "Re:AI in a Toaster!", read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ ], opid: 57265996 }, 57266220: { uid: 2522392, pid: 57266150, subject: "Re:I remember a time...", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ 57266376 ], opid: 57266150 }, 57266566: { uid: 914043, pid: 57265988, subject: "Re:Stupid industry fads", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ 57267460 ], opid: 57265988 }, 57266044: { uid: 666, pid: 57265956, subject: "Re:You can stop reading at \"Orlowski\"", read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ 57266282 ], opid: 57265956 }, 57266038: { uid: 874519, pid: 0, read: 0, points: 4, kids: [ 57266410, 57266434, 57266506, 57266756, 57267632, 57267706 ], opid: 0 }, 57266462: { uid: 729272, pid: 57266018, subject: "Re:Now With AI!", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ 57267442 ], opid: 57266018 }, 57266238: { uid: 62607, pid: 57266018, subject: "Re:Now With AI!", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ 57266390 ], opid: 57266018 }, 57265952: { uid: 666, pid: 57265934, subject: "Re:Stupid industry fads", read: 0, points: -1, kids: [ ], opid: 57265934 }, 57266670: { uid: 1523865, pid: 0, read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 0 }, 57266268: { uid: 666, pid: 57266100, read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ 57266392 ], opid: 57266100 }, 57266374: { uid: 520002, pid: 57265956, subject: "Re:You can stop reading at \"Orlowski\"", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57265956 }, 57265886: { uid: 666, pid: 0, read: 0, points: -1, kids: [ ], opid: 0 }, 57266434: { uid: 666, pid: 57266038, subject: "Re:OP must be joking...", read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ 57267112 ], opid: 57266038 }, 57266348: { uid: 666, pid: 57265988, subject: "Re:Stupid industry fads", read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ ], opid: 57265988 }, 57266282: { uid: 666, pid: 57266044, read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ ], opid: 57266044 }, 57267462: { uid: 1102107, pid: 57266018, read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57266018 }, 57266060: { uid: 60879, pid: 57265956, subject: "Re:You can stop reading at \"Orlowski\"", read: 0, points: 4, kids: [ ], opid: 57265956 }, 57265938: { uid: 666, pid: 0, read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ 57266188 ], opid: 0 }, 57266458: { uid: 892839, pid: 57265934, subject: "Re:Stupid industry fads", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57265934 }, 57266126: { uid: 2036122, pid: 57265934, subject: "Re:Stupid industry fads", read: 0, points: 3, kids: [ 57267508 ], opid: 57265934 }, 57266582: { uid: 914043, pid: 57266188, subject: "Re:Journalists Always Get It Wrong", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 57266188 }, 57265996: { uid: 133289, pid: 57265970, subject: "Re:AI in a Toaster!", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ 57266042, 57266298, 57266460, 57266490, 57266706, 57267236 ], opid: 57265970 }, 57266104: { uid: 1062886, pid: 0, read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ ], opid: 0 }, 57266426: { uid: 666, pid: 0, read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ ], opid: 0 }, 57265984: { uid: 666, pid: 0, read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ ], opid: 0 }, 57266136: { uid: 25149, pid: 0, read: 0, points: 1, kids: [ 57266222, 57266526 ], opid: 0 }, 57267132: { uid: 874519, pid: 57266756, subject: "Re:OP must be joking...", read: 0, points: 2, kids: [ 57267662 ], opid: 57266756 }, 57267236: { uid: 666, pid: 57265996, subject: "Re:AI in a Toaster!", read: 0, points: 0, kids: [ ], opid: 57265996 }, 57266022: { uid: 666, pid: 57265934, subject: "Re:Stupid industry fads", read: 0, points: 3, kids: [ 57266692 ], opid: 57265934 } });
1614 D2.thresh_totals({6:{6:{1:97,3:0,2:0}},3:{6:{1:86,3:1,2:10},4:{1:86,3:8,2:3},3:{1:86,3:11,2:0},5:{1:86,3:5,2:6}},2:{6:{1:43,3:1,2:53},4:{1:43,3:8,2:46},3:{1:43,3:17,2:37},2:{1:43,3:54,2:0},5:{1:43,3:5,2:49}},1:{6:{1:36,3:1,2:60},4:{1:36,3:8,2:53},1:{1:36,3:61,2:0},3:{1:36,3:17,2:44},2:{1:36,3:59,2:2},5:{1:36,3:5,2:56}},4:{6:{1:90,3:1,2:6},4:{1:90,3:7,2:0},5:{1:90,3:5,2:2}},0:{6:{1:4,3:1,2:92},4:{1:4,3:8,2:85},1:{1:4,3:70,2:23},3:{1:4,3:17,2:76},0:{1:4,3:93,2:0},2:{1:4,3:59,2:34},5:{1:4,3:5,2:88}},"-1":{6:{1:0,3:1,2:96},3:{1:0,3:17,2:80},2:{1:0,3:59,2:38},1:{1:0,3:70,2:27},4:{1:0,3:8,2:89},0:{1:0,3:95,2:2},"-1":{1:0,3:97,2:0},5:{1:0,3:5,2:92}},5:{6:{1:94,3:1,2:2},5:{1:94,3:3,2:0}}});
1617 D2.root_comments([57265886,57265890,57265934,57265938,57265944,57265956,57265970,57265984,57266016,57266030,57266038,57266066,57266104,57266136,57266150,57266214,57266370,57266426,57266452,57266562,57266590,57266670,57266782,57266928,57267042,57267570]);
1618 D2.root_comments_hash({57266016:1,57267042:1,57266030:1,57266562:1,57266782:1,57266590:1,57266928:1,57266214:1,57265956:1,57266150:1,57266038:1,57266452:1,57265944:1,57266670:1,57267570:1,57265886:1,57265938:1,57266370:1,57266066:1,57265970:1,57266104:1,57266426:1,57265984:1,57265890:1,57265934:1,57266136:1});
1620 D2.d2_comment_order(0);
1623 D2.user_is_admin(0);
1624 D2.user_is_subscriber(0);
1625 D2.user_smallscreen(0);
1626 D2.user_threshold(1);
1627 D2.user_highlightthresh(4);
1630 D2.discussion_id(12580424);
1632 D2.d2_seen('57265886,4,44,4,6,8,4,14,14,4,6,2,20,2,4,8,8,4,2,12,4,6,34,4,10,12,6,4,2,12,32,6,26,6,2,4,10,2,30,14,16,50,22,4,2,6,4,4,2,10,8,16,8,18,6,2,2,28,16,18,2,36,4,16,8,72,8,22,14,6,4,40,26,26,120,114,14,56,20,82,22,156,42,6,2,18,2,12,4,6,6,18,14,48,62,30,44');
1633 D2.more_comments_num(0);
1646 <ul id="commentlisting" class="d2">
1647 <li id="tree_57265886" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
1648 <div id="comment_status_57265886" class="commentstatus"></div>
1649 <div id="comment_57265886" class="cw">
1652 <div id="replyto_57265886"></div>
1654 <ul id="group_57265886">
1655 <li id="hiddens_57265886" class="hide"></li>
1658 </li><li id="tree_57265890" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
1659 <div id="comment_status_57265890" class="commentstatus"></div>
1660 <div id="comment_57265890" class="cw">
1663 <div id="replyto_57265890"></div>
1665 <ul id="group_57265890">
1666 <li id="hiddens_57265890" class="hide"></li>
1669 </li><li id="tree_57265934" class="comment full contain"><span class="ind"></span>
1670 <div id="comment_status_57265934" class="commentstatus"></div>
1671 <div id="comment_57265934" class="cw">
1672 <div id="comment_top_57265934" class="commentTop newcomment">
1674 <h4><a id="comment_link_57265934" name="comment_link_57265934" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57265934" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57265934)" >Stupid industry fads</a>
1677 <span id="comment_score_57265934" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57265934); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>5</a>, Funny)</span></h4>
1679 <div class="details">
1680 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~Spy+Handler">Spy Handler</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~Spy+Handler">( 822350 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
1681 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57265934">
1682 on Thursday September 06, 2018 @04:53PM (<span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57265934">#57265934</a>)
1683 <small><a href="http://asdf.com/" title="http://asdf.com/" class="user_homepage_display">Homepage</a>
1684 <a href="//slashdot.org/~Spy+Handler/journal/" title="Wednesday March 09, 2005 @03:02AM" class="user_journal_display">Journal</a> </small>
1688 <div class="commentBody">
1689 <div id="comment_body_57265934"><p>3D printer in every home will fundamentally change human society</p><p>IoT internet connected belt buckles and toothbrushes will take over the world</p><p>AI will revolutionize consumer electronics</p><p>Net PC from Sun will dominate the computer industry (this one is really old)</p></div>
1692 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57265934">
1693 <span class="ind"></span><a id="reply_link_57265934" class="btn link" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&op=Reply&threshold=1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57265934" onclick="D2.replyTo(57265934); return false;">Reply to This</a> <a href="#" class="comment_share_toggle btn link">Share</a>
1694 <div class="comment_share sharethis-0 hide"><span class="au"></span>
1695 <a class="janrain t" href="#" data-provider="twitter" data-message="Stupid industry fads by Spy Handler @slashdot" data-url="https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57265934" data-title="Stupid industry fads">twitter</a>
1696 <a class="janrain f" href="#" data-provider="facebook" data-message="Stupid industry fads by Spy Handler" data-url="https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57265934" data-title="Stupid industry fads">facebook</a>
1697 <a class="janrain l" href="#" data-provider="linkedin" data-message="Stupid industry fads by Spy Handler" data-url="https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57265934" data-title="Stupid industry fads">linkedin</a>
1698 <a class="g" href="https://plus.google.com/share?url=https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424%26cid=57265934" onclick="javascript:window.open(this.href,'', 'menubar=no,toolbar=no,resizable=yes,scrollbars=yes,height=600,width=600');return false;"><img src="//www.gstatic.com/images/icons/gplus-16.png" alt="Share on Google+"/></a>
1700 <span class="ind"></span><a id="reply_link_57265934" title="Flag this comment as Inappropriate" class="ui-icon flag fright" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&op=flag&threshold=1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57265934" onclick="return false;">Flag as Inappropriate</a>
1704 <div id="replyto_57265934"></div>
1706 <ul id="group_57265934">
1707 <li id="hiddens_57265934" class="hide"></li>
1710 <ul id="commtree_57265934"><li id="tree_57265952" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
1711 <div id="comment_status_57265952" class="commentstatus"></div>
1712 <div id="comment_57265952" class="cw">
1715 <div id="replyto_57265952"></div>
1717 <ul id="group_57265952">
1718 <li id="hiddens_57265952" class="hide"></li>
1721 </li><li id="tree_57265988" class="comment full contain"><span class="ind"></span>
1722 <div id="comment_status_57265988" class="commentstatus"></div>
1723 <div id="comment_57265988" class="cw">
1724 <div id="comment_top_57265988" class="commentTop newcomment">
1726 <h4><a id="comment_link_57265988" name="comment_link_57265988" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57265988" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57265988)" >Re:Stupid industry fads</a>
1729 <span id="comment_score_57265988" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57265988); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>5</a>, Insightful)</span></h4>
1731 <div class="details">
1732 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~ShanghaiBill">ShanghaiBill</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~ShanghaiBill">( 739463 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
1733 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57265988">
1734 on Thursday September 06, 2018 @05:05PM (<span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57265988">#57265988</a>)
1739 <div class="commentBody">
1740 <div id="comment_body_57265988"><p>Excessive hype is always followed by a trough of disillusionment. But as the TOD fades, plenty of mature, practical applications are likely to emerge. The technological naysayers are usually even more wrong than the hypesters.</p><p><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hype_cycle" title="wikipedia.org">Hype cycle</a> [wikipedia.org]</p></div>
1743 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57265988">
1744 <span class="ind"></span><a id="reply_link_57265988" class="btn link" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&op=Reply&threshold=1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57265988" onclick="D2.replyTo(57265988); return false;">Reply to This</a> <span class="ind"></span><a class="btn link" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&threshold=1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&cid=57265934" onclick="return D2.selectParent(57265934)">Parent</a> <a href="#" class="comment_share_toggle btn link">Share</a>
1745 <div class="comment_share sharethis-0 hide"><span class="au"></span>
1746 <a class="janrain t" href="#" data-provider="twitter" data-message="Re:Stupid industry fads by ShanghaiBill @slashdot" data-url="https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57265988" data-title="Re:Stupid industry fads">twitter</a>
1747 <a class="janrain f" href="#" data-provider="facebook" data-message="Re:Stupid industry fads by ShanghaiBill" data-url="https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57265988" data-title="Re:Stupid industry fads">facebook</a>
1748 <a class="janrain l" href="#" data-provider="linkedin" data-message="Re:Stupid industry fads by ShanghaiBill" data-url="https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57265988" data-title="Re:Stupid industry fads">linkedin</a>
1749 <a class="g" href="https://plus.google.com/share?url=https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424%26cid=57265988" onclick="javascript:window.open(this.href,'', 'menubar=no,toolbar=no,resizable=yes,scrollbars=yes,height=600,width=600');return false;"><img src="//www.gstatic.com/images/icons/gplus-16.png" alt="Share on Google+"/></a>
1751 <span class="ind"></span><a id="reply_link_57265988" title="Flag this comment as Inappropriate" class="ui-icon flag fright" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&op=flag&threshold=1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57265988" onclick="return false;">Flag as Inappropriate</a>
1755 <div id="replyto_57265988"></div>
1757 <ul id="group_57265988">
1758 <li id="hiddens_57265988" class="hide"></li>
1761 <ul id="commtree_57265988"><li id="tree_57266056" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
1762 <div id="comment_status_57266056" class="commentstatus"></div>
1763 <div id="comment_57266056" class="cw">
1764 <div id="comment_top_57266056" class="commentTop newcomment">
1766 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266056" name="comment_link_57266056" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266056" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266056)" >Re:</a>
1769 <span id="comment_score_57266056" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266056); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
1771 <div class="details">
1772 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~fahrbot-bot">fahrbot-bot</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~fahrbot-bot">( 874524 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
1773 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266056"></span>
1776 <div class="commentBody">
1777 <div id="comment_body_57266056"><p><div class="quote"><p>Excessive hype is always followed by a trough of disillusionment.</p></div><p>
1778 <b>Pro Tip:</b> Get out in front and mention this *before* taking your date home. Better for her to hear it from you than her working it out on her own<nobr> <wbr></nobr>...<nobr> <wbr></nobr>:-)</p></div>
1781 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266056">
1786 <div id="replyto_57266056"></div>
1788 <ul id="group_57266056">
1789 <li id="hiddens_57266056" class="hide"></li>
1792 </li><li id="tree_57266114" class="comment full contain"><span class="ind"></span>
1793 <div id="comment_status_57266114" class="commentstatus"></div>
1794 <div id="comment_57266114" class="cw">
1795 <div id="comment_top_57266114" class="commentTop newcomment">
1797 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266114" name="comment_link_57266114" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266114" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266114)" >Re:Stupid industry fads</a>
1800 <span id="comment_score_57266114" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266114); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>4</a>, Insightful)</span></h4>
1802 <div class="details">
1803 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~CaptainDork">CaptainDork</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~CaptainDork">( 3678879 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
1804 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266114">
1805 on Thursday September 06, 2018 @05:33PM (<span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266114">#57266114</a>)
1810 <div class="commentBody">
1811 <div id="comment_body_57266114"><p>If smart phones and tablets are any indicator<nobr> <wbr></nobr>...</p><p>AI, too, is an evolutionary dead end.</p><p>It's a buzz word with a vacuous definition.</p></div>
1814 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266114">
1815 <span class="ind"></span><a id="reply_link_57266114" class="btn link" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&op=Reply&threshold=1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57266114" onclick="D2.replyTo(57266114); return false;">Reply to This</a> <span class="ind"></span><a class="btn link" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&threshold=1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&cid=57265988" onclick="return D2.selectParent(57265988)">Parent</a> <a href="#" class="comment_share_toggle btn link">Share</a>
1816 <div class="comment_share sharethis-0 hide"><span class="au"></span>
1817 <a class="janrain t" href="#" data-provider="twitter" data-message="Re:Stupid industry fads by CaptainDork @slashdot" data-url="https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266114" data-title="Re:Stupid industry fads">twitter</a>
1818 <a class="janrain f" href="#" data-provider="facebook" data-message="Re:Stupid industry fads by CaptainDork" data-url="https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266114" data-title="Re:Stupid industry fads">facebook</a>
1819 <a class="janrain l" href="#" data-provider="linkedin" data-message="Re:Stupid industry fads by CaptainDork" data-url="https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266114" data-title="Re:Stupid industry fads">linkedin</a>
1820 <a class="g" href="https://plus.google.com/share?url=https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424%26cid=57266114" onclick="javascript:window.open(this.href,'', 'menubar=no,toolbar=no,resizable=yes,scrollbars=yes,height=600,width=600');return false;"><img src="//www.gstatic.com/images/icons/gplus-16.png" alt="Share on Google+"/></a>
1822 <span class="ind"></span><a id="reply_link_57266114" title="Flag this comment as Inappropriate" class="ui-icon flag fright" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&op=flag&threshold=1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57266114" onclick="return false;">Flag as Inappropriate</a>
1826 <div id="replyto_57266114"></div>
1828 <ul id="group_57266114">
1829 <li id="hiddens_57266114" class="hide"></li>
1832 <ul id="commtree_57266114"><li id="tree_57266716" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
1833 <div id="comment_status_57266716" class="commentstatus"></div>
1834 <div id="comment_57266716" class="cw">
1835 <div id="comment_top_57266716" class="commentTop newcomment">
1837 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266716" name="comment_link_57266716" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266716" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266716)" >Re:</a>
1840 <span id="comment_score_57266716" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266716); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
1842 <div class="details">
1843 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~Q-Hack!">Q-Hack!</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~Q-Hack!">( 37846 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
1844 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266716"></span>
1847 <div class="commentBody">
1848 <div id="comment_body_57266716"><p>Not a lot different than back in the 1950's when the trend was to create all manor of odd gadgets to make life easier. Those deemed useful are still around... The rest can be found in junk markets around the world. But hey, the Cracker-barrel's of the future will still need stuff to decorate their walls with.</p></div>
1851 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266716">
1856 <div id="replyto_57266716"></div>
1858 <ul id="group_57266716">
1859 <li id="hiddens_57266716" class="hide"></li>
1862 <ul id="commtree_57266716"><li id="tree_57267214" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
1863 <div id="comment_status_57267214" class="commentstatus"></div>
1864 <div id="comment_57267214" class="cw">
1865 <div id="comment_top_57267214" class="commentTop newcomment">
1867 <h4><a id="comment_link_57267214" name="comment_link_57267214" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57267214" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57267214)" >Re:</a>
1870 <span id="comment_score_57267214" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57267214); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
1872 <div class="details">
1873 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~CaptainDork">CaptainDork</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~CaptainDork">( 3678879 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
1874 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57267214"></span>
1877 <div class="commentBody">
1878 <div id="comment_body_57267214"><p>In reaction to your sig:</p><p>I recently re-read "Nineteen Eighty-Four," because my first reading was so long ago.</p><p>Good read, but what a goddam depressing book!</p></div>
1881 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57267214">
1886 <div id="replyto_57267214"></div>
1888 <ul id="group_57267214">
1889 <li id="hiddens_57267214" class="hide"></li>
1892 </li></ul></li></ul></li><li id="tree_57266182" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
1893 <div id="comment_status_57266182" class="commentstatus"></div>
1894 <div id="comment_57266182" class="cw">
1897 <div id="replyto_57266182"></div>
1899 <ul id="group_57266182">
1900 <li id="hiddens_57266182" class="hide"></li>
1903 </li><li id="tree_57266236" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
1904 <div id="comment_status_57266236" class="commentstatus"></div>
1905 <div id="comment_57266236" class="cw">
1906 <div id="comment_top_57266236" class="commentTop newcomment">
1908 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266236" name="comment_link_57266236" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266236" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266236)" >Re:</a>
1911 <span id="comment_score_57266236" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266236); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
1913 <div class="details">
1914 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~magzteel">magzteel</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~magzteel">( 5013587 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
1915 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266236"></span>
1918 <div class="commentBody">
1919 <div id="comment_body_57266236"><p><div class="quote"><p>Excessive hype is always followed by a trough of disillusionment. But as the TOD fades, plenty of mature, practical applications are likely to emerge. The technological naysayers are usually even more wrong than the hypesters.</p><p> <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hype_cycle" title="wikipedia.org">Hype cycle</a> [wikipedia.org] </p></div><p>Back in the early PC days, when you had to hook up a cassette player to load your application, and then another one to load your data, we used to tell people they could store recipes on their TRS-80 personal computer. This was not much of a productivity enhancer. I'm sure based on this experience some people would have thought PC's were useless and had no future.</p><p>And then floppy disks and spreadsheets were invented.</p></div>
1922 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266236">
1927 <div id="replyto_57266236"></div>
1929 <ul id="group_57266236">
1930 <li id="hiddens_57266236" class="hide"></li>
1933 </li><li id="tree_57266348" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
1934 <div id="comment_status_57266348" class="commentstatus"></div>
1935 <div id="comment_57266348" class="cw">
1938 <div id="replyto_57266348"></div>
1940 <ul id="group_57266348">
1941 <li id="hiddens_57266348" class="hide"></li>
1944 </li><li id="tree_57266566" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
1945 <div id="comment_status_57266566" class="commentstatus"></div>
1946 <div id="comment_57266566" class="cw">
1947 <div id="comment_top_57266566" class="commentTop newcomment">
1949 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266566" name="comment_link_57266566" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266566" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266566)" >Re:</a>
1952 <span id="comment_score_57266566" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266566); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
1954 <div class="details">
1955 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~jythie">jythie</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~jythie">( 914043 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
1956 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266566"></span>
1959 <div class="commentBody">
1960 <div id="comment_body_57266566">It is really difficult to say if the naysayers or hypesters are more often right or wrong. One problem with looking back at negative guesses is we only really remember the ones that turned out to be wrong since the evidence is in modern use today, while all the naysayers that we right, well, the things they were right about faded into obscurity.</div>
1963 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266566">
1968 <div id="replyto_57266566"></div>
1970 <ul id="group_57266566">
1971 <li id="hiddens_57266566" class="hide"></li>
1974 <ul id="commtree_57266566"><li id="tree_57267460" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
1975 <div id="comment_status_57267460" class="commentstatus"></div>
1976 <div id="comment_57267460" class="cw">
1977 <div id="comment_top_57267460" class="commentTop newcomment">
1979 <h4><a id="comment_link_57267460" name="comment_link_57267460" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57267460" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57267460)" >Re:</a>
1982 <span id="comment_score_57267460" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57267460); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
1984 <div class="details">
1985 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~ShanghaiBill">ShanghaiBill</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~ShanghaiBill">( 739463 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
1986 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57267460"></span>
1989 <div class="commentBody">
1990 <div id="comment_body_57267460"><p>You only count as a "true" naysayer if you are negative about an overhyped trend with groupies and fanbois, not about an obviously stupid idea.</p><p>The naysayers were right about the Segway, but that was an easy target, since it reached peak hype before it had even been shown to the public.</p><p>Other tech failures were Iridium, Zune, Pebble, Juicero. But none of these were hyped as world changing technology.</p></div>
1993 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57267460">
1998 <div id="replyto_57267460"></div>
2000 <ul id="group_57267460">
2001 <li id="hiddens_57267460" class="hide"></li>
2004 </li></ul></li><li id="tree_57266662" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
2005 <div id="comment_status_57266662" class="commentstatus"></div>
2006 <div id="comment_57266662" class="cw">
2009 <div id="replyto_57266662"></div>
2011 <ul id="group_57266662">
2012 <li id="hiddens_57266662" class="hide"></li>
2015 <ul id="commtree_57266662"><li id="tree_57267478" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
2016 <div id="comment_status_57267478" class="commentstatus"></div>
2017 <div id="comment_57267478" class="cw">
2018 <div id="comment_top_57267478" class="commentTop newcomment">
2020 <h4><a id="comment_link_57267478" name="comment_link_57267478" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57267478" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57267478)" >Re:</a>
2023 <span id="comment_score_57267478" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57267478); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
2025 <div class="details">
2026 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~ShanghaiBill">ShanghaiBill</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~ShanghaiBill">( 739463 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
2027 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57267478"></span>
2030 <div class="commentBody">
2031 <div id="comment_body_57267478"><p><div class="quote"><p>In the long term only 1/20 companies really make it.</p></div><p>Success of a technology is rarely correlated with the success of particular companies. Silicon Valley is littered with plaques marking the graves of semiconductor pioneering companies. Few of them survived. Yet semiconductors have been the greatest technological success since fire was tamed.</p><p>For another example, look at aviation. It took 66 years to go from Kitty Hawk to the Sea of Tranquility. Yet how many airlines made money during those years? Almost none.</p></div>
2034 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57267478">
2039 <div id="replyto_57267478"></div>
2041 <ul id="group_57267478">
2042 <li id="hiddens_57267478" class="hide"></li>
2045 </li></ul></li><li id="hidestring_57265988"><noscript><b class='more'><span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&threshold=-1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57265988">3 replies</a> beneath your current threshold.</b></noscript></li></ul></li><li id="tree_57265994" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
2046 <div id="comment_status_57265994" class="commentstatus"></div>
2047 <div id="comment_57265994" class="cw">
2048 <div id="comment_top_57265994" class="commentTop newcomment">
2050 <h4><a id="comment_link_57265994" name="comment_link_57265994" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57265994" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57265994)" >Re:</a>
2053 <span id="comment_score_57265994" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57265994); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>1</a>)</span></h4>
2055 <div class="details">
2056 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~atherophage">atherophage</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~atherophage">( 2481624 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
2057 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57265994"></span>
2060 <div class="commentBody">
2061 <div id="comment_body_57265994">Prognosticators have been wrong before. While it is easy to poke fun at the unusual who knows, perhaps in a few years dental floss will come with AI. The thought of not having AI floss will be unthinkable.</div>
2064 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57265994">
2069 <div id="replyto_57265994"></div>
2071 <ul id="group_57265994">
2072 <li id="hiddens_57265994" class="hide"></li>
2075 <ul id="commtree_57265994"><li id="tree_57267522" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
2076 <div id="comment_status_57267522" class="commentstatus"></div>
2077 <div id="comment_57267522" class="cw">
2080 <div id="replyto_57267522"></div>
2082 <ul id="group_57267522">
2083 <li id="hiddens_57267522" class="hide"></li>
2086 </li><li id="hidestring_57265994"><noscript><b class='more'><span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&threshold=-1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57265994">1 reply</a> beneath your current threshold.</b></noscript></li></ul></li><li id="tree_57266022" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
2087 <div id="comment_status_57266022" class="commentstatus"></div>
2088 <div id="comment_57266022" class="cw">
2089 <div id="comment_top_57266022" class="commentTop newcomment">
2091 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266022" name="comment_link_57266022" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266022" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266022)" >Re:</a>
2094 <span id="comment_score_57266022" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266022); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>3</a>, Interesting)</span></h4>
2096 <div class="details">
2097 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span>Anonymous Coward</span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
2098 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266022"></span>
2101 <div class="commentBody">
2102 <div id="comment_body_57266022"><p>As much as I am a nerd, I blame "nerds" for this. There is this whole new fad of being a "techie", watching Big Bang Theory, owning a Tesla, and generally being absolutely ignorant about real science, technology and math while "pretending" to be a nerd. I used "pretending" but there may be some legitimate attempt but it is hard to tell if someone is a fake nerd or just a stupid nerd. I think this trend partly follows from women trying to follow the (tech) money and then men trying to follow the women.</p><p>This<span class="substr"> </span></p></div>
2105 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266022">
2110 <div id="replyto_57266022"></div>
2112 <ul id="group_57266022">
2113 <li id="hiddens_57266022" class="hide"></li>
2116 <ul id="commtree_57266022"><li id="tree_57266692" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
2117 <div id="comment_status_57266692" class="commentstatus"></div>
2118 <div id="comment_57266692" class="cw">
2119 <div id="comment_top_57266692" class="commentTop newcomment">
2121 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266692" name="comment_link_57266692" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266692" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266692)" >Re:</a>
2124 <span id="comment_score_57266692" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266692); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
2126 <div class="details">
2127 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~AbRASiON">AbRASiON</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~AbRASiON">( 589899 )</a></span></a> <a href="/faq/subscriptions.shtml#subscription_other_advantages">*</a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
2128 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266692"></span>
2131 <div class="commentBody">
2132 <div id="comment_body_57266692"><p>I don't know that there's a lot of these people but they do exist, for certain yes. The 'watching big bang theory' is the kicker, once someone admits watching that, you know they're very unlikely to be a 'proper nerd' for lack of a better term.</p><p>Considering they only have partial skills in technology then, we can likely guess, if they work in the industry, they're probably higher on the ladder than us and paid more though<nobr> <wbr></nobr>:/ like most management / consultant types.</p></div>
2135 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266692">
2140 <div id="replyto_57266692"></div>
2142 <ul id="group_57266692">
2143 <li id="hiddens_57266692" class="hide"></li>
2146 </li></ul></li><li id="tree_57266126" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
2147 <div id="comment_status_57266126" class="commentstatus"></div>
2148 <div id="comment_57266126" class="cw">
2149 <div id="comment_top_57266126" class="commentTop newcomment">
2151 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266126" name="comment_link_57266126" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266126" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266126)" >Re:</a>
2154 <span id="comment_score_57266126" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266126); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>3</a>)</span></h4>
2156 <div class="details">
2157 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~JMJimmy">JMJimmy</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~JMJimmy">( 2036122 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
2158 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266126"></span>
2161 <div class="commentBody">
2162 <div id="comment_body_57266126"><p>The thing no one can consider is time.</p><p>"AI" being jammed into things now is probably lame, awkward, and of very limited use. Much like computers were back in the punch card days with devices that. Less than 100 years later we've got computers in our pocket. We are in the early days of AI - we'll look back on it decades from now as we do with things like: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sp7MHZY2ADI" title="youtube.com">https://www.youtube.com/watch?...<span class="substr"> </span></a> [youtube.com] </p><p>This article is just another example of someone who can't see past their nose to the road ahead and the million differen</p></div>
2165 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266126">
2170 <div id="replyto_57266126"></div>
2172 <ul id="group_57266126">
2173 <li id="hiddens_57266126" class="hide"></li>
2176 <ul id="commtree_57266126"><li id="tree_57267508" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
2177 <div id="comment_status_57267508" class="commentstatus"></div>
2178 <div id="comment_57267508" class="cw">
2181 <div id="replyto_57267508"></div>
2183 <ul id="group_57267508">
2184 <li id="hiddens_57267508" class="hide"></li>
2187 </li><li id="hidestring_57266126"><noscript><b class='more'><span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&threshold=-1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57266126">1 reply</a> beneath your current threshold.</b></noscript></li></ul></li><li id="tree_57266226" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
2188 <div id="comment_status_57266226" class="commentstatus"></div>
2189 <div id="comment_57266226" class="cw">
2192 <div id="replyto_57266226"></div>
2194 <ul id="group_57266226">
2195 <li id="hiddens_57266226" class="hide"></li>
2198 </li><li id="tree_57266382" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
2199 <div id="comment_status_57266382" class="commentstatus"></div>
2200 <div id="comment_57266382" class="cw">
2203 <div id="replyto_57266382"></div>
2205 <ul id="group_57266382">
2206 <li id="hiddens_57266382" class="hide"></li>
2209 </li><li id="tree_57266458" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
2210 <div id="comment_status_57266458" class="commentstatus"></div>
2211 <div id="comment_57266458" class="cw">
2212 <div id="comment_top_57266458" class="commentTop newcomment">
2214 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266458" name="comment_link_57266458" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266458" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266458)" >Re:</a>
2217 <span id="comment_score_57266458" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266458); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
2219 <div class="details">
2220 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~AHuxley">AHuxley</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~AHuxley">( 892839 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
2221 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266458"></span>
2224 <div class="commentBody">
2225 <div id="comment_body_57266458">Good for a few workers over the decade of hype.</div>
2228 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266458">
2233 <div id="replyto_57266458"></div>
2235 <ul id="group_57266458">
2236 <li id="hiddens_57266458" class="hide"></li>
2239 </li><li id="tree_57267434" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
2240 <div id="comment_status_57267434" class="commentstatus"></div>
2241 <div id="comment_57267434" class="cw">
2242 <div id="comment_top_57267434" class="commentTop newcomment">
2244 <h4><a id="comment_link_57267434" name="comment_link_57267434" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57267434" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57267434)" >Re:</a>
2247 <span id="comment_score_57267434" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57267434); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
2249 <div class="details">
2250 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~m00sh">m00sh</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~m00sh">( 2538182 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
2251 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57267434"></span>
2254 <div class="commentBody">
2255 <div id="comment_body_57267434"><p><div class="quote"><p>3D printer in every home will fundamentally change human society</p><p>IoT internet connected belt buckles and toothbrushes will take over the world</p><p>AI will revolutionize consumer electronics</p><p>Net PC from Sun will dominate the computer industry (this one is really old)</p></div><p>I don't know about home but it plays a big part in manufacturing. There are very specialized and successful medical companies that use 3d printing.
2257 </p><p>Don't know about belt buckles but fitbit, apple watch, garmin has been worth billions of dollars and fundamentally changed the way a lot of people do things.
2259 </p><p>I don't know about NetPC but what about the cloud? The hype that we would all put all our stuff in the cloud blah blah actually materialized. There are many companies who own no hardware except the dev la<span class="substr"> </span></p></div>
2262 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57267434">
2267 <div id="replyto_57267434"></div>
2269 <ul id="group_57267434">
2270 <li id="hiddens_57267434" class="hide"></li>
2273 </li><li id="tree_57267440" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
2274 <div id="comment_status_57267440" class="commentstatus"></div>
2275 <div id="comment_57267440" class="cw">
2276 <div id="comment_top_57267440" class="commentTop newcomment">
2278 <h4><a id="comment_link_57267440" name="comment_link_57267440" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57267440" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57267440)" >Re:</a>
2281 <span id="comment_score_57267440" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57267440); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
2283 <div class="details">
2284 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~lokedhs">lokedhs</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~lokedhs">( 672255 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
2285 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57267440"></span>
2288 <div class="commentBody">
2289 <div id="comment_body_57267440">Net PC was not from Sun. I should I know, I worked for them during that era. What they had was JavaStation, which was a neat idea but ahead of its time. That concept is now realised by the Chromebook.
2291 Net PC was a Compaq thing, if I recall correctly. However, Wikipedia tells me it was Oracle, so perhaps the Compaq device was called something else.</div>
2294 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57267440">
2299 <div id="replyto_57267440"></div>
2301 <ul id="group_57267440">
2302 <li id="hiddens_57267440" class="hide"></li>
2305 </li><li id="hidestring_57265934"><noscript><b class='more'><span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&threshold=-1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57265934">3 replies</a> beneath your current threshold.</b></noscript></li></ul></li><li id="tree_57265938" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
2306 <div id="comment_status_57265938" class="commentstatus"></div>
2307 <div id="comment_57265938" class="cw">
2310 <div id="replyto_57265938"></div>
2312 <ul id="group_57265938">
2313 <li id="hiddens_57265938" class="hide"></li>
2316 <ul id="commtree_57265938"><li id="tree_57266188" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
2317 <div id="comment_status_57266188" class="commentstatus"></div>
2318 <div id="comment_57266188" class="cw">
2319 <div id="comment_top_57266188" class="commentTop newcomment">
2321 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266188" name="comment_link_57266188" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266188" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266188)" >Re:</a>
2324 <span id="comment_score_57266188" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266188); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
2326 <div class="details">
2327 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~bobbied">bobbied</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~bobbied">( 2522392 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
2328 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266188"></span>
2331 <div class="commentBody">
2332 <div id="comment_body_57266188"><p><div class="quote"><p>Example: Apple will go under...any day now....since 1984</p></div><p>But they've been totally correct in not predicting the "Year of the Linux Desktop" has come. </p><p>You win a few and lose a few. </p></div>
2335 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266188">
2340 <div id="replyto_57266188"></div>
2342 <ul id="group_57266188">
2343 <li id="hiddens_57266188" class="hide"></li>
2346 <ul id="commtree_57266188"><li id="tree_57266582" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
2347 <div id="comment_status_57266582" class="commentstatus"></div>
2348 <div id="comment_57266582" class="cw">
2349 <div id="comment_top_57266582" class="commentTop newcomment">
2351 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266582" name="comment_link_57266582" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266582" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266582)" >Re:</a>
2354 <span id="comment_score_57266582" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266582); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
2356 <div class="details">
2357 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~jythie">jythie</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~jythie">( 914043 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
2358 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266582"></span>
2361 <div class="commentBody">
2362 <div id="comment_body_57266582">*nod* to expand on this.... true, Apple never did go under. But look how many computer companies started up around the same time and did. It is fun to look at the successes and compare them to the naysayers who were wrong, but the ones who were right, well, their predictions did not leave much to talk about today.</div>
2365 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266582">
2370 <div id="replyto_57266582"></div>
2372 <ul id="group_57266582">
2373 <li id="hiddens_57266582" class="hide"></li>
2376 </li></ul></li></ul></li><li id="tree_57265944" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
2377 <div id="comment_status_57265944" class="commentstatus"></div>
2378 <div id="comment_57265944" class="cw">
2381 <div id="replyto_57265944"></div>
2383 <ul id="group_57265944">
2384 <li id="hiddens_57265944" class="hide"></li>
2387 <ul id="commtree_57265944"><li id="tree_57266018" class="comment full contain"><span class="ind"></span>
2388 <div id="comment_status_57266018" class="commentstatus"></div>
2389 <div id="comment_57266018" class="cw">
2390 <div id="comment_top_57266018" class="commentTop newcomment">
2392 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266018" name="comment_link_57266018" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266018" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266018)" >Re:Now With AI!</a>
2395 <span id="comment_score_57266018" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266018); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>5</a>, Informative)</span></h4>
2397 <div class="details">
2398 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~ShanghaiBill">ShanghaiBill</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~ShanghaiBill">( 739463 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
2399 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266018">
2400 on Thursday September 06, 2018 @05:13PM (<span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266018">#57266018</a>)
2405 <div class="commentBody">
2406 <div id="comment_body_57266018"><p><div class="quote"><p>Gee, I could have sworn we already HAD the AI craze back in the late 80s. Or was it early 90s?</p></div><p>It was the 1980s. It had faded long before 1990.</p><p>But there was an earlier AI craze in the 1960s, based on perceptrons. That faded by 1970.</p><p>The 1980 AI hype cycle was driven by "expert systems" and "Lisp machines".</p><p>The latest cycle started in 2006 with the publication of the <a href="http://science.sciencemag.org/content/313/5786/504" title="sciencemag.org">seminal paper on deep learning</a> [sciencemag.org], and has so far lasted far longer than any previous AI hype cycle.</p></div>
2409 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266018">
2410 <span class="ind"></span><a id="reply_link_57266018" class="btn link" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&op=Reply&threshold=1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57266018" onclick="D2.replyTo(57266018); return false;">Reply to This</a> <span class="ind"></span><a class="btn link" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&threshold=1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&cid=57265944" onclick="return D2.selectParent(57265944)">Parent</a> <a href="#" class="comment_share_toggle btn link">Share</a>
2411 <div class="comment_share sharethis-0 hide"><span class="au"></span>
2412 <a class="janrain t" href="#" data-provider="twitter" data-message="Re:Now With AI! by ShanghaiBill @slashdot" data-url="https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266018" data-title="Re:Now With AI!">twitter</a>
2413 <a class="janrain f" href="#" data-provider="facebook" data-message="Re:Now With AI! by ShanghaiBill" data-url="https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266018" data-title="Re:Now With AI!">facebook</a>
2414 <a class="janrain l" href="#" data-provider="linkedin" data-message="Re:Now With AI! by ShanghaiBill" data-url="https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266018" data-title="Re:Now With AI!">linkedin</a>
2415 <a class="g" href="https://plus.google.com/share?url=https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424%26cid=57266018" onclick="javascript:window.open(this.href,'', 'menubar=no,toolbar=no,resizable=yes,scrollbars=yes,height=600,width=600');return false;"><img src="//www.gstatic.com/images/icons/gplus-16.png" alt="Share on Google+"/></a>
2417 <span class="ind"></span><a id="reply_link_57266018" title="Flag this comment as Inappropriate" class="ui-icon flag fright" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&op=flag&threshold=1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57266018" onclick="return false;">Flag as Inappropriate</a>
2421 <div id="replyto_57266018"></div>
2423 <ul id="group_57266018">
2424 <li id="hiddens_57266018" class="hide"></li>
2427 <ul id="commtree_57266018"><li id="tree_57266132" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
2428 <div id="comment_status_57266132" class="commentstatus"></div>
2429 <div id="comment_57266132" class="cw">
2430 <div id="comment_top_57266132" class="commentTop newcomment">
2432 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266132" name="comment_link_57266132" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266132" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266132)" >Re:</a>
2435 <span id="comment_score_57266132" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266132); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
2437 <div class="details">
2438 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~CaptainDork">CaptainDork</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~CaptainDork">( 3678879 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
2439 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266132"></span>
2442 <div class="commentBody">
2443 <div id="comment_body_57266132"><p>I go way back, too.</p><p>AI had an unambiguous definition that eroded under stress because the industry came to the realization that the "I" part (intelligence) used the human mind as the high bar.</p><p>The second epiphany came when no one could fabricate an AI that would simply refuse to cooperate if Facebook was unreachable.</p></div>
2446 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266132">
2451 <div id="replyto_57266132"></div>
2453 <ul id="group_57266132">
2454 <li id="hiddens_57266132" class="hide"></li>
2457 </li><li id="tree_57266238" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
2458 <div id="comment_status_57266238" class="commentstatus"></div>
2459 <div id="comment_57266238" class="cw">
2460 <div id="comment_top_57266238" class="commentTop newcomment">
2462 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266238" name="comment_link_57266238" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266238" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266238)" >Re:</a>
2465 <span id="comment_score_57266238" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266238); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
2467 <div class="details">
2468 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~Pseudonym">Pseudonym</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~Pseudonym">( 62607 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
2469 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266238"></span>
2472 <div class="commentBody">
2473 <div id="comment_body_57266238"><p>In the 90s it was all "knowledge-based systems" and in the noughties it was all "intelligent agents".</p></div>
2476 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266238">
2481 <div id="replyto_57266238"></div>
2483 <ul id="group_57266238">
2484 <li id="hiddens_57266238" class="hide"></li>
2487 <ul id="commtree_57266238"><li id="tree_57266390" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
2488 <div id="comment_status_57266390" class="commentstatus"></div>
2489 <div id="comment_57266390" class="cw">
2490 <div id="comment_top_57266390" class="commentTop newcomment">
2492 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266390" name="comment_link_57266390" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266390" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266390)" >Re:</a>
2495 <span id="comment_score_57266390" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266390); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
2497 <div class="details">
2498 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~ShanghaiBill">ShanghaiBill</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~ShanghaiBill">( 739463 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
2499 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266390"></span>
2502 <div class="commentBody">
2503 <div id="comment_body_57266390"><p><div class="quote"><p>In the 90s it was all "knowledge-based systems" and in the noughties it was all "intelligent agents".</p></div><p>Yes, but those generated far less hype than what happened in the 60s, 80s, and teenies.</p><p>The big things in the 90s and noughties were the web and e-commerce.</p></div>
2506 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266390">
2511 <div id="replyto_57266390"></div>
2513 <ul id="group_57266390">
2514 <li id="hiddens_57266390" class="hide"></li>
2517 </li></ul></li><li id="tree_57266462" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
2518 <div id="comment_status_57266462" class="commentstatus"></div>
2519 <div id="comment_57266462" class="cw">
2520 <div id="comment_top_57266462" class="commentTop newcomment">
2522 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266462" name="comment_link_57266462" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266462" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266462)" >Re:</a>
2525 <span id="comment_score_57266462" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266462); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
2527 <div class="details">
2528 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~CWCheese">CWCheese</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~CWCheese">( 729272 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
2529 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266462"></span>
2532 <div class="commentBody">
2533 <div id="comment_body_57266462">Thanks for the <i>Lisp</i> reference! I fondly remember learning Lisp in an AI class during college in the 80s. Actually enjoyed programming Lisp because it could be so terse and do so much very rapidly. However, we really had no good applications to use for it, other than having an application learn the best way to win a chess game. I chose not to pursue AI as a career and haven't suffered for that.</div>
2536 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266462">
2541 <div id="replyto_57266462"></div>
2543 <ul id="group_57266462">
2544 <li id="hiddens_57266462" class="hide"></li>
2547 <ul id="commtree_57266462"><li id="tree_57267442" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
2548 <div id="comment_status_57267442" class="commentstatus"></div>
2549 <div id="comment_57267442" class="cw">
2550 <div id="comment_top_57267442" class="commentTop newcomment">
2552 <h4><a id="comment_link_57267442" name="comment_link_57267442" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57267442" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57267442)" >Re:</a>
2555 <span id="comment_score_57267442" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57267442); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
2557 <div class="details">
2558 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~ShanghaiBill">ShanghaiBill</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~ShanghaiBill">( 739463 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
2559 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57267442"></span>
2562 <div class="commentBody">
2563 <div id="comment_body_57267442"><p><div class="quote"><p>I chose not to pursue AI as a career and haven't suffered for that.</p></div><p>Learning Lisp would not have helped you. Modern AI uses mostly Python based libraries such as Tensorflow and PyTorch. C++ is used for performance critical stuff. Nobody uses Lisp for AI anymore. It was a dead end.</p></div>
2566 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57267442">
2571 <div id="replyto_57267442"></div>
2573 <ul id="group_57267442">
2574 <li id="hiddens_57267442" class="hide"></li>
2577 </li></ul></li><li id="tree_57267462" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
2578 <div id="comment_status_57267462" class="commentstatus"></div>
2579 <div id="comment_57267462" class="cw">
2580 <div id="comment_top_57267462" class="commentTop newcomment">
2582 <h4><a id="comment_link_57267462" name="comment_link_57267462" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57267462" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57267462)" >Fifth Generation</a>
2585 <span id="comment_score_57267462" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57267462); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
2587 <div class="details">
2588 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~mcswell">mcswell</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~mcswell">( 1102107 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
2589 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57267462"></span>
2592 <div class="commentBody">
2593 <div id="comment_body_57267462"><p>Fueling the hype in the 1980s AI cycle was the Japanese Fifth Generation project, for which a stated goal was to leapfrog the West's computer technology and skills. People like Edward Feigenbaum and Pamela McCorduck used the FUD generated around this project to call for increased funding, claiming in their 1983 book 'The Fifth Generation: Japan’s Computer Challenge to the World' that "America needs a national plan of action, a kind of space shuttle program for the knowledge systems of the future." A<span class="substr"> </span></p></div>
2596 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57267462">
2601 <div id="replyto_57267462"></div>
2603 <ul id="group_57267462">
2604 <li id="hiddens_57267462" class="hide"></li>
2607 </li></ul></li><li id="tree_57266100" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
2608 <div id="comment_status_57266100" class="commentstatus"></div>
2609 <div id="comment_57266100" class="cw">
2610 <div id="comment_top_57266100" class="commentTop newcomment">
2612 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266100" name="comment_link_57266100" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266100" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266100)" >Re:</a>
2615 <span id="comment_score_57266100" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266100); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
2617 <div class="details">
2618 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~Torodung">Torodung</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~Torodung">( 31985 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
2619 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266100"></span>
2622 <div class="commentBody">
2623 <div id="comment_body_57266100"><p><div class="quote"><p>Cats on the blockchain, anyone?</p></div><p>Well, at the very least, every zig should be on the blockchain. Don't know about Cats.</p></div>
2626 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266100">
2631 <div id="replyto_57266100"></div>
2633 <ul id="group_57266100">
2634 <li id="hiddens_57266100" class="hide"></li>
2637 <ul id="commtree_57266100"><li id="tree_57266268" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
2638 <div id="comment_status_57266268" class="commentstatus"></div>
2639 <div id="comment_57266268" class="cw">
2642 <div id="replyto_57266268"></div>
2644 <ul id="group_57266268">
2645 <li id="hiddens_57266268" class="hide"></li>
2648 <ul id="commtree_57266268"><li id="tree_57266392" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
2649 <div id="comment_status_57266392" class="commentstatus"></div>
2650 <div id="comment_57266392" class="cw">
2653 <div id="replyto_57266392"></div>
2655 <ul id="group_57266392">
2656 <li id="hiddens_57266392" class="hide"></li>
2659 </li><li id="hidestring_57266268"><noscript><b class='more'><span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&threshold=-1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57266268">1 reply</a> beneath your current threshold.</b></noscript></li></ul></li><li id="hidestring_57266100"><noscript><b class='more'><span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&threshold=-1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57266100">1 reply</a> beneath your current threshold.</b></noscript></li></ul></li></ul></li><li id="tree_57265956" class="comment full contain"><span class="ind"></span>
2660 <div id="comment_status_57265956" class="commentstatus"></div>
2661 <div id="comment_57265956" class="cw">
2662 <div id="comment_top_57265956" class="commentTop newcomment">
2664 <h4><a id="comment_link_57265956" name="comment_link_57265956" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57265956" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57265956)" >You can stop reading at "Orlowski"</a>
2667 <span id="comment_score_57265956" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57265956); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>4</a>, Interesting)</span></h4>
2669 <div class="details">
2670 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~serviscope_minor">serviscope_minor</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~serviscope_minor">( 664417 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
2671 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57265956">
2672 on Thursday September 06, 2018 @04:59PM (<span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57265956">#57265956</a>)
2673 <small><a href="//slashdot.org/~serviscope_minor/journal/" title="Thursday October 06, 2011 @02:59PM" class="user_journal_display">Journal</a> </small>
2677 <div class="commentBody">
2678 <div id="comment_body_57265956"><p>Andrew Orlowski of The Register is basically a professional dickhead. His main goal seems to be to be as obnoxious and ignorant as possible presumably with the goal of trolling the readership. He's pretty much the reason I stopped reading the Register because of the constant streem of utter bullshit from that guy.</p></div>
2681 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57265956">
2682 <span class="ind"></span><a id="reply_link_57265956" class="btn link" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&op=Reply&threshold=1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57265956" onclick="D2.replyTo(57265956); return false;">Reply to This</a> <a href="#" class="comment_share_toggle btn link">Share</a>
2683 <div class="comment_share sharethis-0 hide"><span class="au"></span>
2684 <a class="janrain t" href="#" data-provider="twitter" data-message="You can stop reading at "Orlowski" by serviscope_minor @slashdot" data-url="https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57265956" data-title="You can stop reading at "Orlowski"">twitter</a>
2685 <a class="janrain f" href="#" data-provider="facebook" data-message="You can stop reading at "Orlowski" by serviscope_minor" data-url="https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57265956" data-title="You can stop reading at "Orlowski"">facebook</a>
2686 <a class="janrain l" href="#" data-provider="linkedin" data-message="You can stop reading at "Orlowski" by serviscope_minor" data-url="https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57265956" data-title="You can stop reading at "Orlowski"">linkedin</a>
2687 <a class="g" href="https://plus.google.com/share?url=https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424%26cid=57265956" onclick="javascript:window.open(this.href,'', 'menubar=no,toolbar=no,resizable=yes,scrollbars=yes,height=600,width=600');return false;"><img src="//www.gstatic.com/images/icons/gplus-16.png" alt="Share on Google+"/></a>
2689 <span class="ind"></span><a id="reply_link_57265956" title="Flag this comment as Inappropriate" class="ui-icon flag fright" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&op=flag&threshold=1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57265956" onclick="return false;">Flag as Inappropriate</a>
2693 <div id="replyto_57265956"></div>
2695 <ul id="group_57265956">
2696 <li id="hiddens_57265956" class="hide"></li>
2699 <ul id="commtree_57265956"><li id="tree_57266044" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
2700 <div id="comment_status_57266044" class="commentstatus"></div>
2701 <div id="comment_57266044" class="cw">
2704 <div id="replyto_57266044"></div>
2706 <ul id="group_57266044">
2707 <li id="hiddens_57266044" class="hide"></li>
2710 <ul id="commtree_57266044"><li id="tree_57266282" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
2711 <div id="comment_status_57266282" class="commentstatus"></div>
2712 <div id="comment_57266282" class="cw">
2715 <div id="replyto_57266282"></div>
2717 <ul id="group_57266282">
2718 <li id="hiddens_57266282" class="hide"></li>
2721 </li><li id="hidestring_57266044"><noscript><b class='more'><span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&threshold=-1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57266044">1 reply</a> beneath your current threshold.</b></noscript></li></ul></li><li id="tree_57266060" class="comment full contain"><span class="ind"></span>
2722 <div id="comment_status_57266060" class="commentstatus"></div>
2723 <div id="comment_57266060" class="cw">
2724 <div id="comment_top_57266060" class="commentTop newcomment">
2726 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266060" name="comment_link_57266060" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266060" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266060)" >Re:You can stop reading at "Orlowski"</a>
2729 <span id="comment_score_57266060" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266060); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>4</a>, Interesting)</span></h4>
2731 <div class="details">
2732 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~starless">starless</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~starless">( 60879 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
2733 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266060">
2734 on Thursday September 06, 2018 @05:21PM (<span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266060">#57266060</a>)
2739 <div class="commentBody">
2740 <div id="comment_body_57266060"><p>And also appears to be climate change denier....<br>(at least for some of his Register articles.)</p></div>
2743 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266060">
2744 <span class="ind"></span><a id="reply_link_57266060" class="btn link" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&op=Reply&threshold=1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57266060" onclick="D2.replyTo(57266060); return false;">Reply to This</a> <span class="ind"></span><a class="btn link" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&threshold=1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&cid=57265956" onclick="return D2.selectParent(57265956)">Parent</a> <a href="#" class="comment_share_toggle btn link">Share</a>
2745 <div class="comment_share sharethis-0 hide"><span class="au"></span>
2746 <a class="janrain t" href="#" data-provider="twitter" data-message="Re:You can stop reading at "Orlowski" by starless @slashdot" data-url="https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266060" data-title="Re:You can stop reading at "Orlowski"">twitter</a>
2747 <a class="janrain f" href="#" data-provider="facebook" data-message="Re:You can stop reading at "Orlowski" by starless" data-url="https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266060" data-title="Re:You can stop reading at "Orlowski"">facebook</a>
2748 <a class="janrain l" href="#" data-provider="linkedin" data-message="Re:You can stop reading at "Orlowski" by starless" data-url="https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266060" data-title="Re:You can stop reading at "Orlowski"">linkedin</a>
2749 <a class="g" href="https://plus.google.com/share?url=https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424%26cid=57266060" onclick="javascript:window.open(this.href,'', 'menubar=no,toolbar=no,resizable=yes,scrollbars=yes,height=600,width=600');return false;"><img src="//www.gstatic.com/images/icons/gplus-16.png" alt="Share on Google+"/></a>
2751 <span class="ind"></span><a id="reply_link_57266060" title="Flag this comment as Inappropriate" class="ui-icon flag fright" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&op=flag&threshold=1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57266060" onclick="return false;">Flag as Inappropriate</a>
2755 <div id="replyto_57266060"></div>
2757 <ul id="group_57266060">
2758 <li id="hiddens_57266060" class="hide"></li>
2761 </li><li id="tree_57266374" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
2762 <div id="comment_status_57266374" class="commentstatus"></div>
2763 <div id="comment_57266374" class="cw">
2764 <div id="comment_top_57266374" class="commentTop newcomment">
2766 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266374" name="comment_link_57266374" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266374" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266374)" >Re:</a>
2769 <span id="comment_score_57266374" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266374); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
2771 <div class="details">
2772 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~TJ_Phazerhacki">TJ_Phazerhacki</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~TJ_Phazerhacki">( 520002 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
2773 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266374"></span>
2776 <div class="commentBody">
2777 <div id="comment_body_57266374">So, Walt Mossberg for a new generation?
2782 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266374">
2787 <div id="replyto_57266374"></div>
2789 <ul id="group_57266374">
2790 <li id="hiddens_57266374" class="hide"></li>
2793 </li><li id="hidestring_57265956"><noscript><b class='more'><span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&threshold=-1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57265956">1 reply</a> beneath your current threshold.</b></noscript></li></ul></li><li id="tree_57265970" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
2794 <div id="comment_status_57265970" class="commentstatus"></div>
2795 <div id="comment_57265970" class="cw">
2796 <div id="comment_top_57265970" class="commentTop newcomment">
2798 <h4><a id="comment_link_57265970" name="comment_link_57265970" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57265970" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57265970)" >AI in a Toaster!</a>
2801 <span id="comment_score_57265970" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57265970); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
2803 <div class="details">
2804 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~Zorro">Zorro</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~Zorro">( 15797 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
2805 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57265970"></span>
2808 <div class="commentBody">
2809 <div id="comment_body_57265970"><p>Red Dwarf has already shown why this is a BAD Idea.</p><p>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lhnN4eUiei4</p></div>
2812 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57265970">
2817 <div id="replyto_57265970"></div>
2819 <ul id="group_57265970">
2820 <li id="hiddens_57265970" class="hide"></li>
2823 <ul id="commtree_57265970"><li id="tree_57265996" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
2824 <div id="comment_status_57265996" class="commentstatus"></div>
2825 <div id="comment_57265996" class="cw">
2826 <div id="comment_top_57265996" class="commentTop newcomment">
2828 <h4><a id="comment_link_57265996" name="comment_link_57265996" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57265996" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57265996)" >Re:</a>
2831 <span id="comment_score_57265996" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57265996); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
2833 <div class="details">
2834 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~Revek">Revek</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~Revek">( 133289 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
2835 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57265996"></span>
2838 <div class="commentBody">
2839 <div id="comment_body_57265996"><p>Please learn basic html K, thanks.</p></div>
2842 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57265996">
2847 <div id="replyto_57265996"></div>
2849 <ul id="group_57265996">
2850 <li id="hiddens_57265996" class="hide"></li>
2853 <ul id="commtree_57265996"><li id="tree_57266042" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
2854 <div id="comment_status_57266042" class="commentstatus"></div>
2855 <div id="comment_57266042" class="cw">
2858 <div id="replyto_57266042"></div>
2860 <ul id="group_57266042">
2861 <li id="hiddens_57266042" class="hide"></li>
2864 </li><li id="tree_57266298" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
2865 <div id="comment_status_57266298" class="commentstatus"></div>
2866 <div id="comment_57266298" class="cw">
2869 <div id="replyto_57266298"></div>
2871 <ul id="group_57266298">
2872 <li id="hiddens_57266298" class="hide"></li>
2875 </li><li id="tree_57266460" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
2876 <div id="comment_status_57266460" class="commentstatus"></div>
2877 <div id="comment_57266460" class="cw">
2880 <div id="replyto_57266460"></div>
2882 <ul id="group_57266460">
2883 <li id="hiddens_57266460" class="hide"></li>
2886 </li><li id="tree_57266490" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
2887 <div id="comment_status_57266490" class="commentstatus"></div>
2888 <div id="comment_57266490" class="cw">
2891 <div id="replyto_57266490"></div>
2893 <ul id="group_57266490">
2894 <li id="hiddens_57266490" class="hide"></li>
2897 </li><li id="tree_57266706" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
2898 <div id="comment_status_57266706" class="commentstatus"></div>
2899 <div id="comment_57266706" class="cw">
2900 <div id="comment_top_57266706" class="commentTop newcomment">
2902 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266706" name="comment_link_57266706" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266706" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266706)" >Re:</a>
2905 <span id="comment_score_57266706" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266706); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
2907 <div class="details">
2908 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~AbRASiON">AbRASiON</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~AbRASiON">( 589899 )</a></span></a> <a href="/faq/subscriptions.shtml#subscription_other_advantages">*</a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
2909 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266706"></span>
2912 <div class="commentBody">
2913 <div id="comment_body_57266706"><p>How about slashdot stop being entirely backwards with that shit instead?</p></div>
2916 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266706">
2921 <div id="replyto_57266706"></div>
2923 <ul id="group_57266706">
2924 <li id="hiddens_57266706" class="hide"></li>
2927 </li><li id="tree_57267236" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
2928 <div id="comment_status_57267236" class="commentstatus"></div>
2929 <div id="comment_57267236" class="cw">
2932 <div id="replyto_57267236"></div>
2934 <ul id="group_57267236">
2935 <li id="hiddens_57267236" class="hide"></li>
2938 </li><li id="hidestring_57265996"><noscript><b class='more'><span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&threshold=-1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57265996">5 replies</a> beneath your current threshold.</b></noscript></li></ul></li></ul></li><li id="tree_57265984" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
2939 <div id="comment_status_57265984" class="commentstatus"></div>
2940 <div id="comment_57265984" class="cw">
2943 <div id="replyto_57265984"></div>
2945 <ul id="group_57265984">
2946 <li id="hiddens_57265984" class="hide"></li>
2949 </li><li id="tree_57266016" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
2950 <div id="comment_status_57266016" class="commentstatus"></div>
2951 <div id="comment_57266016" class="cw">
2954 <div id="replyto_57266016"></div>
2956 <ul id="group_57266016">
2957 <li id="hiddens_57266016" class="hide"></li>
2960 <ul id="commtree_57266016"><li id="tree_57266138" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
2961 <div id="comment_status_57266138" class="commentstatus"></div>
2962 <div id="comment_57266138" class="cw">
2965 <div id="replyto_57266138"></div>
2967 <ul id="group_57266138">
2968 <li id="hiddens_57266138" class="hide"></li>
2971 </li><li id="tree_57266386" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
2972 <div id="comment_status_57266386" class="commentstatus"></div>
2973 <div id="comment_57266386" class="cw">
2974 <div id="comment_top_57266386" class="commentTop newcomment">
2976 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266386" name="comment_link_57266386" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266386" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266386)" >Re:</a>
2979 <span id="comment_score_57266386" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266386); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
2981 <div class="details">
2982 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~Applehu+Akbar">Applehu Akbar</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~Applehu+Akbar">( 2968043 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
2983 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266386"></span>
2986 <div class="commentBody">
2987 <div id="comment_body_57266386"><p>But I do like being able to verbally ask my phone to navigate to a contact, without having to squint at a screen in the sun, and get turn by turn directions. Digital assistants have slipped into a place in my life where they do a few useful things. As time goes on, this set will grow larger.</p><p>But I know: "If it works, it's not AI!" "If it's AI, it won't work!"</p></div>
2990 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266386">
2995 <div id="replyto_57266386"></div>
2997 <ul id="group_57266386">
2998 <li id="hiddens_57266386" class="hide"></li>
3001 </li><li id="hidestring_57266016"><noscript><b class='more'><span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&threshold=-1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57266016">1 reply</a> beneath your current threshold.</b></noscript></li></ul></li><li id="tree_57266030" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
3002 <div id="comment_status_57266030" class="commentstatus"></div>
3003 <div id="comment_57266030" class="cw">
3004 <div id="comment_top_57266030" class="commentTop newcomment">
3006 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266030" name="comment_link_57266030" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266030" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266030)" >Aibo</a>
3009 <span id="comment_score_57266030" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266030); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>1</a>)</span></h4>
3011 <div class="details">
3012 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span>Anonymous Coward</span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3013 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266030"></span>
3016 <div class="commentBody">
3017 <div id="comment_body_57266030"><p>If Sony's Aibo lives up to the demos I have seen - that would be one big application. AI as a pet.</p><p>I also use AI (maybe more ML) all the time with photo sorting, image recognition, etc. It is already in the home.</p></div>
3020 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266030">
3025 <div id="replyto_57266030"></div>
3027 <ul id="group_57266030">
3028 <li id="hiddens_57266030" class="hide"></li>
3031 </li><li id="tree_57266038" class="comment full contain"><span class="ind"></span>
3032 <div id="comment_status_57266038" class="commentstatus"></div>
3033 <div id="comment_57266038" class="cw">
3034 <div id="comment_top_57266038" class="commentTop newcomment">
3036 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266038" name="comment_link_57266038" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266038" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266038)" >OP must be joking...</a>
3039 <span id="comment_score_57266038" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266038); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>4</a>, Insightful)</span></h4>
3041 <div class="details">
3042 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~JoeDuncan">JoeDuncan</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~JoeDuncan">( 874519 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3043 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266038">
3044 on Thursday September 06, 2018 @05:17PM (<span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266038">#57266038</a>)
3049 <div class="commentBody">
3050 <div id="comment_body_57266038"><p>... because consumer AI is *ALREADY* ubiquitous and all around us.</p><p>From the face detection in your phone, to the fuzzy logic controllers in washing machines, to the ant colony algorithms being used to route network traffic, to finding directions with google maps, to Netflix and Amazon's recommendation algorithms, to OCR for cheques and mail, to NEST thermostats, to robot vacuum cleaners and lawn mowers, to expert systems in medical diagnosis... (I could keep going)</p><p>AI in consumer products is literally *already* ALL around us.</p><p>Saying that consumer AI "has no future" is like looking around at the world today and saying "personal cars have no future" - it's completely idiotic because to anyone with half an ounce of perception that future is ALREADY here.</p><p>It's like looking at a forest and claiming there are no trees</p></div>
3053 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266038">
3054 <span class="ind"></span><a id="reply_link_57266038" class="btn link" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&op=Reply&threshold=1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57266038" onclick="D2.replyTo(57266038); return false;">Reply to This</a> <a href="#" class="comment_share_toggle btn link">Share</a>
3055 <div class="comment_share sharethis-0 hide"><span class="au"></span>
3056 <a class="janrain t" href="#" data-provider="twitter" data-message="OP must be joking... by JoeDuncan @slashdot" data-url="https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266038" data-title="OP must be joking...">twitter</a>
3057 <a class="janrain f" href="#" data-provider="facebook" data-message="OP must be joking... by JoeDuncan" data-url="https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266038" data-title="OP must be joking...">facebook</a>
3058 <a class="janrain l" href="#" data-provider="linkedin" data-message="OP must be joking... by JoeDuncan" data-url="https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266038" data-title="OP must be joking...">linkedin</a>
3059 <a class="g" href="https://plus.google.com/share?url=https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424%26cid=57266038" onclick="javascript:window.open(this.href,'', 'menubar=no,toolbar=no,resizable=yes,scrollbars=yes,height=600,width=600');return false;"><img src="//www.gstatic.com/images/icons/gplus-16.png" alt="Share on Google+"/></a>
3061 <span class="ind"></span><a id="reply_link_57266038" title="Flag this comment as Inappropriate" class="ui-icon flag fright" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&op=flag&threshold=1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57266038" onclick="return false;">Flag as Inappropriate</a>
3065 <div id="replyto_57266038"></div>
3067 <ul id="group_57266038">
3068 <li id="hiddens_57266038" class="hide"></li>
3071 <ul id="commtree_57266038"><li id="tree_57266410" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
3072 <div id="comment_status_57266410" class="commentstatus"></div>
3073 <div id="comment_57266410" class="cw">
3074 <div id="comment_top_57266410" class="commentTop newcomment">
3076 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266410" name="comment_link_57266410" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266410" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266410)" >Re:</a>
3079 <span id="comment_score_57266410" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266410); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
3081 <div class="details">
3082 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~grahamsz">grahamsz</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~grahamsz">( 150076 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3083 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266410"></span>
3086 <div class="commentBody">
3087 <div id="comment_body_57266410"><p>Yeah it seems like it is a natural fit in optimizing the things we do.</p><p>Even though I don't routinely use my phone as an alarm clock, it still knows when i'm likely to get up and if I plug it in at bed time it'll do a good job of figuring out when i'm likely to get up and adjusts its charging rate to be done about an hour before then. Yet if I plug it in a 3pm then it'll assume i want as much charge as possible and charge as fast as it can. It's not rocket science, but it's useful.</p><p>Do I need a dishwasher with<span class="substr"> </span></p></div>
3090 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266410">
3095 <div id="replyto_57266410"></div>
3097 <ul id="group_57266410">
3098 <li id="hiddens_57266410" class="hide"></li>
3101 <ul id="commtree_57266410"><li id="tree_57266524" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
3102 <div id="comment_status_57266524" class="commentstatus"></div>
3103 <div id="comment_57266524" class="cw">
3104 <div id="comment_top_57266524" class="commentTop newcomment">
3106 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266524" name="comment_link_57266524" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266524" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266524)" >Re:</a>
3109 <span id="comment_score_57266524" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266524); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
3111 <div class="details">
3112 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~JoeDuncan">JoeDuncan</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~JoeDuncan">( 874519 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3113 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266524"></span>
3116 <div class="commentBody">
3117 <div id="comment_body_57266524"><p><div class="quote"><p>Do I need a dishwasher with a screen that I can talk to?</p></div><p>Nope, but I'm willing to bet it has an embedded fuzzy logic controller in it to control water levels.</p></div>
3120 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266524">
3125 <div id="replyto_57266524"></div>
3127 <ul id="group_57266524">
3128 <li id="hiddens_57266524" class="hide"></li>
3131 </li><li id="tree_57267474" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
3132 <div id="comment_status_57267474" class="commentstatus"></div>
3133 <div id="comment_57267474" class="cw">
3134 <div id="comment_top_57267474" class="commentTop newcomment">
3136 <h4><a id="comment_link_57267474" name="comment_link_57267474" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57267474" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57267474)" >Re:</a>
3139 <span id="comment_score_57267474" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57267474); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
3141 <div class="details">
3142 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~mcswell">mcswell</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~mcswell">( 1102107 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3143 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57267474"></span>
3146 <div class="commentBody">
3147 <div id="comment_body_57267474"><p>"Do I need a dishwasher with a screen that I can talk to?" Printers have a screen. You can't talk to it (at least you're not supposed to--when aggravated, I've been know to do so, and not kindly). But try to decipher what's on that screen. I claim that printers are not any easier to use than they were in 1984 (which is when I got my first dot matrix printer). You (ok, I) *still* can't figure out what's wrong with them, despite the screen.</p></div>
3150 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57267474">
3155 <div id="replyto_57267474"></div>
3157 <ul id="group_57267474">
3158 <li id="hiddens_57267474" class="hide"></li>
3161 </li></ul></li><li id="tree_57266434" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
3162 <div id="comment_status_57266434" class="commentstatus"></div>
3163 <div id="comment_57266434" class="cw">
3166 <div id="replyto_57266434"></div>
3168 <ul id="group_57266434">
3169 <li id="hiddens_57266434" class="hide"></li>
3172 <ul id="commtree_57266434"><li id="tree_57267112" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
3173 <div id="comment_status_57267112" class="commentstatus"></div>
3174 <div id="comment_57267112" class="cw">
3175 <div id="comment_top_57267112" class="commentTop newcomment">
3177 <h4><a id="comment_link_57267112" name="comment_link_57267112" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57267112" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57267112)" >Re:</a>
3180 <span id="comment_score_57267112" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57267112); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
3182 <div class="details">
3183 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~JoeDuncan">JoeDuncan</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~JoeDuncan">( 874519 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3184 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57267112"></span>
3187 <div class="commentBody">
3188 <div id="comment_body_57267112"><p><div class="quote"><p> None of the tings you mention actually contain any real artificial intelligence in the sense of being able to making decisions in the face of unknown circumstances and data sources.</p></div><p>They do actually.</p><p>Roombas have to be able to adapt to unknown obstacles and uncertain sensory input (could get blocked, partially occluded etc...).</p><p>Embedded fuzzy logic controllers (also used in anti-lock brakes) have to be able to maintain a steady output signal given uncertain input (wear and tear on the mechanics, grit...) that can vary wildly in an unknown manner.</p><p>OCR systems need to be able to tell the difference between a cheque and unknown things, like night club flyers, and they deal with hand written<span class="substr"> </span></p></div>
3191 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57267112">
3196 <div id="replyto_57267112"></div>
3198 <ul id="group_57267112">
3199 <li id="hiddens_57267112" class="hide"></li>
3202 </li></ul></li><li id="tree_57266506" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
3203 <div id="comment_status_57266506" class="commentstatus"></div>
3204 <div id="comment_57266506" class="cw">
3205 <div id="comment_top_57266506" class="commentTop newcomment">
3207 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266506" name="comment_link_57266506" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266506" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266506)" >Re:</a>
3210 <span id="comment_score_57266506" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266506); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>1</a>)</span></h4>
3212 <div class="details">
3213 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~AHuxley">AHuxley</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~AHuxley">( 892839 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3214 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266506"></span>
3217 <div class="commentBody">
3218 <div id="comment_body_57266506">Re "face detection" is not AI. Its a really big and fast database. Filled with faces the police know about and random people walking past CCTV.<br>
3219 Re "fuzzy logic controllers in washing machines" A set amount of power, water, weight of laundry is not AI. Just good programming within set limits.<br>
3220 Re "'finding directions" with maps that are created and set. <br>
3221 Re "recommendation algorithms" that is set by past people buying things and another person showing the same interests. More to do with collecting lots</div>
3224 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266506">
3229 <div id="replyto_57266506"></div>
3231 <ul id="group_57266506">
3232 <li id="hiddens_57266506" class="hide"></li>
3235 <ul id="commtree_57266506"><li id="tree_57267056" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
3236 <div id="comment_status_57267056" class="commentstatus"></div>
3237 <div id="comment_57267056" class="cw">
3238 <div id="comment_top_57267056" class="commentTop newcomment">
3240 <h4><a id="comment_link_57267056" name="comment_link_57267056" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57267056" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57267056)" >Re:</a>
3243 <span id="comment_score_57267056" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57267056); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
3245 <div class="details">
3246 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~JoeDuncan">JoeDuncan</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~JoeDuncan">( 874519 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3247 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57267056"></span>
3250 <div class="commentBody">
3251 <div id="comment_body_57267056"><p><span class="substr"> </span><div class="quote"><p>..."face detection" is not AI. Its a really big and fast database. Filled with faces the police know...</p></div><p>...and just HOW do the faces "police know" get matched to this database? Explain without reference to AI.</p><p><div class="quote"><p>..."fuzzy logic controllers in washing machines" A set amount of power, water, weight of laundry is not AI.</p></div><p>No it isn't, but you're a fool if you think your washing machine is that simple these days. It DOES take fuzzy logic to adapt to things like wear and tear on the machine, arbitrarily changing water pressures and temperatures, etc... and still maintain consistent performance.</p><p><div class="quote"><p>"'finding directions" with maps that are created and set.</p></div><p>...and using AI algorithms to find the best path.</p><p>Blah blah blah... you get the point. You've deliberately downplayed the AI aspect</p></div>
3254 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57267056">
3259 <div id="replyto_57267056"></div>
3261 <ul id="group_57267056">
3262 <li id="hiddens_57267056" class="hide"></li>
3265 </li></ul></li><li id="tree_57266756" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
3266 <div id="comment_status_57266756" class="commentstatus"></div>
3267 <div id="comment_57266756" class="cw">
3270 <div id="replyto_57266756"></div>
3272 <ul id="group_57266756">
3273 <li id="hiddens_57266756" class="hide"></li>
3276 <ul id="commtree_57266756"><li id="tree_57267132" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
3277 <div id="comment_status_57267132" class="commentstatus"></div>
3278 <div id="comment_57267132" class="cw">
3279 <div id="comment_top_57267132" class="commentTop newcomment">
3281 <h4><a id="comment_link_57267132" name="comment_link_57267132" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57267132" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57267132)" >Re:</a>
3284 <span id="comment_score_57267132" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57267132); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
3286 <div class="details">
3287 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~JoeDuncan">JoeDuncan</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~JoeDuncan">( 874519 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3288 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57267132"></span>
3291 <div class="commentBody">
3292 <div id="comment_body_57267132"><p>You are clearly uneducated, Troll.</p><p>If you actually wish to enlighten yourself, I'd start here: <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artificial_intelligence" title="wikipedia.org">https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/...</a> [wikipedia.org] </p></div>
3295 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57267132">
3300 <div id="replyto_57267132"></div>
3302 <ul id="group_57267132">
3303 <li id="hiddens_57267132" class="hide"></li>
3306 <ul id="commtree_57267132"><li id="tree_57267662" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
3307 <div id="comment_status_57267662" class="commentstatus"></div>
3308 <div id="comment_57267662" class="cw">
3311 <div id="replyto_57267662"></div>
3313 <ul id="group_57267662">
3314 <li id="hiddens_57267662" class="hide"></li>
3317 </li><li id="hidestring_57267132"><noscript><b class='more'><span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&threshold=-1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57267132">1 reply</a> beneath your current threshold.</b></noscript></li></ul></li></ul></li><li id="tree_57267632" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
3318 <div id="comment_status_57267632" class="commentstatus"></div>
3319 <div id="comment_57267632" class="cw">
3320 <div id="comment_top_57267632" class="commentTop newcomment">
3322 <h4><a id="comment_link_57267632" name="comment_link_57267632" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57267632" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57267632)" >Re:</a>
3325 <span id="comment_score_57267632" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57267632); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
3327 <div class="details">
3328 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~hazem">hazem</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~hazem">( 472289 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3329 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57267632"></span>
3332 <div class="commentBody">
3333 <div id="comment_body_57267632"><p><div class="quote"><p>From the face detection in your phone, to the fuzzy logic controllers in washing machines, to the ant colony algorithms being used to route network traffic, to finding directions with google maps, to Netflix and Amazon's recommendation algorithms, to OCR for cheques and mail, to NEST thermostats, to robot vacuum cleaners and lawn mowers, to expert systems in medical diagnosis... (I could keep going)</p></div><p>When I took an AI class a few years ago, one of my favorite things the professor said was, "What we called 'AI' yesterday is simply the algorithm for how we do a thing today."</p></div>
3336 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57267632">
3341 <div id="replyto_57267632"></div>
3343 <ul id="group_57267632">
3344 <li id="hiddens_57267632" class="hide"></li>
3347 </li><li id="tree_57267706" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
3348 <div id="comment_status_57267706" class="commentstatus"></div>
3349 <div id="comment_57267706" class="cw">
3352 <div id="replyto_57267706"></div>
3354 <ul id="group_57267706">
3355 <li id="hiddens_57267706" class="hide"></li>
3358 </li><li id="hidestring_57266038"><noscript><b class='more'><span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&threshold=-1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57266038">3 replies</a> beneath your current threshold.</b></noscript></li></ul></li><li id="tree_57266066" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
3359 <div id="comment_status_57266066" class="commentstatus"></div>
3360 <div id="comment_57266066" class="cw">
3363 <div id="replyto_57266066"></div>
3365 <ul id="group_57266066">
3366 <li id="hiddens_57266066" class="hide"></li>
3369 </li><li id="tree_57266104" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
3370 <div id="comment_status_57266104" class="commentstatus"></div>
3371 <div id="comment_57266104" class="cw">
3372 <div id="comment_top_57266104" class="commentTop newcomment">
3374 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266104" name="comment_link_57266104" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266104" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266104)" >AI's Strength</a>
3377 <span id="comment_score_57266104" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266104); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
3379 <div class="details">
3380 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~thePsychologist">thePsychologist</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~thePsychologist">( 1062886 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3381 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266104"></span>
3384 <div class="commentBody">
3385 <div id="comment_body_57266104"><p>AI (i.e. machine learning/neural networks) is really good at optimizing stuff, so its natural strength shows when you have hundreds of thousands of entities in a system. Examples are the electricity grid, playing Go, and a department store's inventory.</p><p>In our individual lives, AI seems more like another drop in the bucket of too much technology, and I think one day we'll realize that less is more when it comes to the stuff in our homes.</p></div>
3388 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266104">
3393 <div id="replyto_57266104"></div>
3395 <ul id="group_57266104">
3396 <li id="hiddens_57266104" class="hide"></li>
3399 </li><li id="tree_57266136" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
3400 <div id="comment_status_57266136" class="commentstatus"></div>
3401 <div id="comment_57266136" class="cw">
3402 <div id="comment_top_57266136" class="commentTop newcomment">
3404 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266136" name="comment_link_57266136" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266136" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266136)" >Getting concerned myself</a>
3407 <span id="comment_score_57266136" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266136); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>1</a>)</span></h4>
3409 <div class="details">
3410 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~SuperKendall">SuperKendall</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~SuperKendall">( 25149 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3411 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266136"></span>
3414 <div class="commentBody">
3415 <div id="comment_body_57266136"><p>I was looking at new fridges recently as a friend was asking for a recommendation, and it's alarming how trying to find a fridge without a screen is getting to be like trying to find a cell phone without a camera... it really limits your options.</p><p>The only way they could make fridges any worse is the if screens also played CNN constantly when not in use, like in an airport... you can absolutely see subsidized ad-fridges coming down the pipeline.</p></div>
3418 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266136">
3423 <div id="replyto_57266136"></div>
3425 <ul id="group_57266136">
3426 <li id="hiddens_57266136" class="hide"></li>
3429 <ul id="commtree_57266136"><li id="tree_57266222" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
3430 <div id="comment_status_57266222" class="commentstatus"></div>
3431 <div id="comment_57266222" class="cw">
3432 <div id="comment_top_57266222" class="commentTop newcomment">
3434 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266222" name="comment_link_57266222" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266222" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266222)" >Re:</a>
3437 <span id="comment_score_57266222" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266222); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
3439 <div class="details">
3440 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~lgw">lgw</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~lgw">( 121541 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3441 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266222"></span>
3444 <div class="commentBody">
3445 <div id="comment_body_57266222"><p>Seems like only the highest and lowest-end fridges lack screens these days (as well as ice/water in the door, something else I could do without).</p></div>
3448 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266222">
3453 <div id="replyto_57266222"></div>
3455 <ul id="group_57266222">
3456 <li id="hiddens_57266222" class="hide"></li>
3459 <ul id="commtree_57266222"><li id="tree_57267484" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
3460 <div id="comment_status_57267484" class="commentstatus"></div>
3461 <div id="comment_57267484" class="cw">
3462 <div id="comment_top_57267484" class="commentTop newcomment">
3464 <h4><a id="comment_link_57267484" name="comment_link_57267484" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57267484" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57267484)" >Re:</a>
3467 <span id="comment_score_57267484" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57267484); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
3469 <div class="details">
3470 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~mcswell">mcswell</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~mcswell">( 1102107 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3471 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57267484"></span>
3474 <div class="commentBody">
3475 <div id="comment_body_57267484"><p>Come to my house. The refr *has* an ice/water dispenser in the door, but it hasn't worked for over a year. I think the tube to the water dispenser is frozen, and if it gets thawed, it just freezes up again. Same with the water dispenser on the refr nearest my office at work.</p><p>As for the ice dispenser on our refr, we never used it, so I took it out and got lots more room in the freezer. If we want ice cubes, we make them in trays, like the 1960s.</p></div>
3478 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57267484">
3483 <div id="replyto_57267484"></div>
3485 <ul id="group_57267484">
3486 <li id="hiddens_57267484" class="hide"></li>
3489 </li></ul></li><li id="tree_57266526" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
3490 <div id="comment_status_57266526" class="commentstatus"></div>
3491 <div id="comment_57266526" class="cw">
3494 <div id="replyto_57266526"></div>
3496 <ul id="group_57266526">
3497 <li id="hiddens_57266526" class="hide"></li>
3500 <ul id="commtree_57266526"><li id="tree_57266808" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
3501 <div id="comment_status_57266808" class="commentstatus"></div>
3502 <div id="comment_57266808" class="cw">
3503 <div id="comment_top_57266808" class="commentTop newcomment">
3505 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266808" name="comment_link_57266808" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266808" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266808)" >Re:</a>
3508 <span id="comment_score_57266808" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266808); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>3</a>)</span></h4>
3510 <div class="details">
3511 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~sheramil">sheramil</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~sheramil">( 921315 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3512 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266808"></span>
3515 <div class="commentBody">
3516 <div id="comment_body_57266808"><p><div class="quote"><p>What the hell does a fridge need a screen for?</p></div><p>You can connect it to a webcam inside the fridge and see if the light goes out when you close the door.</p></div>
3519 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266808">
3524 <div id="replyto_57266808"></div>
3526 <ul id="group_57266808">
3527 <li id="hiddens_57266808" class="hide"></li>
3530 </li></ul></li><li id="hidestring_57266136"><noscript><b class='more'><span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&threshold=-1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57266136">1 reply</a> beneath your current threshold.</b></noscript></li></ul></li><li id="tree_57266150" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
3531 <div id="comment_status_57266150" class="commentstatus"></div>
3532 <div id="comment_57266150" class="cw">
3533 <div id="comment_top_57266150" class="commentTop newcomment">
3535 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266150" name="comment_link_57266150" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266150" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266150)" >I remember a time...</a>
3538 <span id="comment_score_57266150" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266150); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
3540 <div class="details">
3541 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~DalM">Dallas May</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~DalM">( 4891515 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3542 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266150"></span>
3545 <div class="commentBody">
3546 <div id="comment_body_57266150"><p>My uncle was a computer scientist for a National Lab. He retired 15 or so years ago. I remember just after my grandmother first got internet, he didn't have it at his home yet because he didn't believe it was safe -this was probably 1997 or 98, and I remember him talking to me about how disappointed he was with the internet. "It was supposed to be this great thing. It's useless. It'll never amount to anything."</p><p>Yeah, he was wrong.</p></div>
3549 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266150">
3554 <div id="replyto_57266150"></div>
3556 <ul id="group_57266150">
3557 <li id="hiddens_57266150" class="hide"></li>
3560 <ul id="commtree_57266150"><li id="tree_57266220" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
3561 <div id="comment_status_57266220" class="commentstatus"></div>
3562 <div id="comment_57266220" class="cw">
3563 <div id="comment_top_57266220" class="commentTop newcomment">
3565 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266220" name="comment_link_57266220" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266220" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266220)" >Re:</a>
3568 <span id="comment_score_57266220" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266220); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
3570 <div class="details">
3571 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~bobbied">bobbied</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~bobbied">( 2522392 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3572 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266220"></span>
3575 <div class="commentBody">
3576 <div id="comment_body_57266220"><p><div class="quote"><p>My uncle was a computer scientist for a National Lab. He retired 15 or so years ago. I remember just after my grandmother first got internet, he didn't have it at his home yet because he didn't believe it was safe -this was probably 1997 or 98, and I remember him talking to me about how disappointed he was with the internet. "It was supposed to be this great thing. It's useless. It'll never amount to anything."</p><p>Yeah, he was wrong.</p></div><p>Was he? Was he really? </p><p>How much of the internet is truly useful and how much is just trash? Judging by my inbox, the number of E-mail in my inbox the ratio 1s more than 10 to 1 SPAM to worth while messages (And that's AFTER the SPAM filters.) </p><p>I find that this ratio pretty much governs the whole of the internet.. Where 1/10th of it is actually something of use and the rest is just useless junk. </p><p>So he's not that wrong. </p></div>
3579 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266220">
3584 <div id="replyto_57266220"></div>
3586 <ul id="group_57266220">
3587 <li id="hiddens_57266220" class="hide"></li>
3590 <ul id="commtree_57266220"><li id="tree_57266376" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
3591 <div id="comment_status_57266376" class="commentstatus"></div>
3592 <div id="comment_57266376" class="cw">
3595 <div id="replyto_57266376"></div>
3597 <ul id="group_57266376">
3598 <li id="hiddens_57266376" class="hide"></li>
3601 </li><li id="hidestring_57266220"><noscript><b class='more'><span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&threshold=-1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57266220">1 reply</a> beneath your current threshold.</b></noscript></li></ul></li><li id="tree_57266402" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
3602 <div id="comment_status_57266402" class="commentstatus"></div>
3603 <div id="comment_57266402" class="cw">
3606 <div id="replyto_57266402"></div>
3608 <ul id="group_57266402">
3609 <li id="hiddens_57266402" class="hide"></li>
3612 <ul id="commtree_57266402"><li id="tree_57267490" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
3613 <div id="comment_status_57267490" class="commentstatus"></div>
3614 <div id="comment_57267490" class="cw">
3615 <div id="comment_top_57267490" class="commentTop newcomment">
3617 <h4><a id="comment_link_57267490" name="comment_link_57267490" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57267490" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57267490)" >Re:</a>
3620 <span id="comment_score_57267490" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57267490); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
3622 <div class="details">
3623 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~mcswell">mcswell</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~mcswell">( 1102107 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3624 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57267490"></span>
3627 <div class="commentBody">
3628 <div id="comment_body_57267490"><p>And here you (and I) are.</p></div>
3631 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57267490">
3636 <div id="replyto_57267490"></div>
3638 <ul id="group_57267490">
3639 <li id="hiddens_57267490" class="hide"></li>
3642 </li></ul></li><li id="hidestring_57266150"><noscript><b class='more'><span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&threshold=-1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57266150">1 reply</a> beneath your current threshold.</b></noscript></li></ul></li><li id="tree_57266214" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
3643 <div id="comment_status_57266214" class="commentstatus"></div>
3644 <div id="comment_57266214" class="cw">
3645 <div id="comment_top_57266214" class="commentTop newcomment">
3647 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266214" name="comment_link_57266214" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266214" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266214)" >I heard...</a>
3650 <span id="comment_score_57266214" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266214); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>1</a>)</span></h4>
3652 <div class="details">
3653 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~Hentai007">Hentai007</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~Hentai007">( 188457 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3654 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266214"></span>
3657 <div class="commentBody">
3658 <div id="comment_body_57266214"><p>AI is turning frogs gay.</p></div>
3661 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266214">
3666 <div id="replyto_57266214"></div>
3668 <ul id="group_57266214">
3669 <li id="hiddens_57266214" class="hide"></li>
3672 <ul id="commtree_57266214"><li id="tree_57266712" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
3673 <div id="comment_status_57266712" class="commentstatus"></div>
3674 <div id="comment_57266712" class="cw">
3675 <div id="comment_top_57266712" class="commentTop newcomment">
3677 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266712" name="comment_link_57266712" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266712" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266712)" >Re:</a>
3680 <span id="comment_score_57266712" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266712); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
3682 <div class="details">
3683 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~AbRASiON">AbRASiON</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~AbRASiON">( 589899 )</a></span></a> <a href="/faq/subscriptions.shtml#subscription_other_advantages">*</a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3684 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266712"></span>
3687 <div class="commentBody">
3688 <div id="comment_body_57266712"><p>That's actually not true, the frogs are only gay for pay.</p></div>
3691 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266712">
3696 <div id="replyto_57266712"></div>
3698 <ul id="group_57266712">
3699 <li id="hiddens_57266712" class="hide"></li>
3702 </li></ul></li><li id="tree_57266370" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
3703 <div id="comment_status_57266370" class="commentstatus"></div>
3704 <div id="comment_57266370" class="cw">
3707 <div id="replyto_57266370"></div>
3709 <ul id="group_57266370">
3710 <li id="hiddens_57266370" class="hide"></li>
3713 </li><li id="tree_57266426" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
3714 <div id="comment_status_57266426" class="commentstatus"></div>
3715 <div id="comment_57266426" class="cw">
3718 <div id="replyto_57266426"></div>
3720 <ul id="group_57266426">
3721 <li id="hiddens_57266426" class="hide"></li>
3724 </li><li id="tree_57266452" class="comment full contain"><span class="ind"></span>
3725 <div id="comment_status_57266452" class="commentstatus"></div>
3726 <div id="comment_57266452" class="cw">
3727 <div id="comment_top_57266452" class="commentTop newcomment">
3729 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266452" name="comment_link_57266452" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266452" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266452)" >Nobody buys something because of AI</a>
3732 <span id="comment_score_57266452" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266452); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>3</a>)</span></h4>
3734 <div class="details">
3735 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~Laxator2">Laxator2</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~Laxator2">( 973549 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3736 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266452">
3737 on Thursday September 06, 2018 @06:46PM (<span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266452">#57266452</a>)
3742 <div class="commentBody">
3743 <div id="comment_body_57266452"><p>I did not see any example where someone says: "I did not buy that product because it lacked AI".</p><p>I did not hear from anyone that they need AI so they are going out of their way to buy it. In its current form AI is good for pattern recognition in some cases, for example, face identification in photos.<br>The only customers are corporations with massive collections of personal data to analyze, but not individual consumers.<br>I believe AI has been over-hyped and pushed in areas where it is not usable in its current form (like self-driving cars) and we start to see the backlash.</p><p>I've already seen stories saying that the medical diagnoses made by IBM's Watson are just plain wrong. More examples will follow.</p></div>
3746 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266452">
3747 <span class="ind"></span><a id="reply_link_57266452" class="btn link" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&op=Reply&threshold=1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57266452" onclick="D2.replyTo(57266452); return false;">Reply to This</a> <a href="#" class="comment_share_toggle btn link">Share</a>
3748 <div class="comment_share sharethis-0 hide"><span class="au"></span>
3749 <a class="janrain t" href="#" data-provider="twitter" data-message="Nobody buys something because of AI by Laxator2 @slashdot" data-url="https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266452" data-title="Nobody buys something because of AI">twitter</a>
3750 <a class="janrain f" href="#" data-provider="facebook" data-message="Nobody buys something because of AI by Laxator2" data-url="https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266452" data-title="Nobody buys something because of AI">facebook</a>
3751 <a class="janrain l" href="#" data-provider="linkedin" data-message="Nobody buys something because of AI by Laxator2" data-url="https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266452" data-title="Nobody buys something because of AI">linkedin</a>
3752 <a class="g" href="https://plus.google.com/share?url=https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424%26cid=57266452" onclick="javascript:window.open(this.href,'', 'menubar=no,toolbar=no,resizable=yes,scrollbars=yes,height=600,width=600');return false;"><img src="//www.gstatic.com/images/icons/gplus-16.png" alt="Share on Google+"/></a>
3754 <span class="ind"></span><a id="reply_link_57266452" title="Flag this comment as Inappropriate" class="ui-icon flag fright" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&op=flag&threshold=1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=57266452" onclick="return false;">Flag as Inappropriate</a>
3758 <div id="replyto_57266452"></div>
3760 <ul id="group_57266452">
3761 <li id="hiddens_57266452" class="hide"></li>
3764 <ul id="commtree_57266452"><li id="tree_57267392" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
3765 <div id="comment_status_57267392" class="commentstatus"></div>
3766 <div id="comment_57267392" class="cw">
3767 <div id="comment_top_57267392" class="commentTop newcomment">
3769 <h4><a id="comment_link_57267392" name="comment_link_57267392" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57267392" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57267392)" >Re:</a>
3772 <span id="comment_score_57267392" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57267392); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
3774 <div class="details">
3775 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~m00sh">m00sh</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~m00sh">( 2538182 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3776 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57267392"></span>
3779 <div class="commentBody">
3780 <div id="comment_body_57267392"><p><div class="quote"><p>I did not see any example where someone says: "I did not buy that product because it lacked AI".</p><p>I did not hear from anyone that they need AI so they are going out of their way to buy it. In its current form AI is good for pattern recognition in some cases, for example, face identification in photos.
3781 The only customers are corporations with massive collections of personal data to analyze, but not individual consumers.
3782 I believe AI has been over-hyped and pushed in areas where it is not usable in its current form (like self-driving cars) and we start to see the backlash.</p><p>I've already seen stories saying that the medical diagnoses made by IBM's Watson are just plain wrong. More examples will follow.</p></div><p>What about Google home and Alexa?
3784 </p><p>How do you recognize pedestrians in self-driving cars without AI?
3786 </p><p>IBM Watson was wrong quite a bit but it won jeopardy.</p></div>
3789 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57267392">
3794 <div id="replyto_57267392"></div>
3796 <ul id="group_57267392">
3797 <li id="hiddens_57267392" class="hide"></li>
3800 </li></ul></li><li id="tree_57266562" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
3801 <div id="comment_status_57266562" class="commentstatus"></div>
3802 <div id="comment_57266562" class="cw">
3803 <div id="comment_top_57266562" class="commentTop newcomment">
3805 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266562" name="comment_link_57266562" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266562" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266562)" >First they ignore you, ...</a>
3808 <span id="comment_score_57266562" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266562); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>1</a>)</span></h4>
3810 <div class="details">
3811 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~Maxo-Texas">Maxo-Texas</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~Maxo-Texas">( 864189 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3812 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266562"></span>
3815 <div class="commentBody">
3816 <div id="comment_body_57266562"><p>First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win.</p><p>Mahatma Gandhi</p><p>This field is moving so fast compared to the 90s.</p></div>
3819 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266562">
3824 <div id="replyto_57266562"></div>
3826 <ul id="group_57266562">
3827 <li id="hiddens_57266562" class="hide"></li>
3830 </li><li id="tree_57266590" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
3831 <div id="comment_status_57266590" class="commentstatus"></div>
3832 <div id="comment_57266590" class="cw">
3833 <div id="comment_top_57266590" class="commentTop newcomment">
3835 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266590" name="comment_link_57266590" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266590" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266590)" >It's a dead end because it's not very good anyway</a>
3838 <span id="comment_score_57266590" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266590); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
3840 <div class="details">
3841 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~Rick+Schumann">Rick Schumann</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~Rick+Schumann">( 4662797 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3842 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266590"></span>
3845 <div class="commentBody">
3846 <div id="comment_body_57266590">So-called 'AI' is over-hyped and under-performing.</div>
3849 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266590">
3854 <div id="replyto_57266590"></div>
3856 <ul id="group_57266590">
3857 <li id="hiddens_57266590" class="hide"></li>
3860 </li><li id="tree_57266670" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
3861 <div id="comment_status_57266670" class="commentstatus"></div>
3862 <div id="comment_57266670" class="cw">
3863 <div id="comment_top_57266670" class="commentTop newcomment">
3865 <h4><a id="comment_link_57266670" name="comment_link_57266670" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57266670" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57266670)" >Another AI winter?</a>
3868 <span id="comment_score_57266670" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57266670); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
3870 <div class="details">
3871 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~OneHundredAndTen">OneHundredAndTen</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~OneHundredAndTen">( 1523865 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3872 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57266670"></span>
3875 <div class="commentBody">
3876 <div id="comment_body_57266670">The AI bubble seems to be starting to deflate. It may not pop, but it will likely carry on shrinking. Most people already know that Alex and co. are little more than gimmicks, good for party games, grins and giggles, and little more. The AI community seems to be making the same mistakes they made in the late 60s and 70s. The second AI winter is nigh.</div>
3879 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57266670">
3884 <div id="replyto_57266670"></div>
3886 <ul id="group_57266670">
3887 <li id="hiddens_57266670" class="hide"></li>
3890 </li><li id="tree_57266782" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
3891 <div id="comment_status_57266782" class="commentstatus"></div>
3892 <div id="comment_57266782" class="cw">
3895 <div id="replyto_57266782"></div>
3897 <ul id="group_57266782">
3898 <li id="hiddens_57266782" class="hide"></li>
3901 </li><li id="tree_57266928" class="comment hidden"><span class="ind"></span>
3902 <div id="comment_status_57266928" class="commentstatus"></div>
3903 <div id="comment_57266928" class="cw">
3906 <div id="replyto_57266928"></div>
3908 <ul id="group_57266928">
3909 <li id="hiddens_57266928" class="hide"></li>
3912 </li><li id="tree_57267042" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
3913 <div id="comment_status_57267042" class="commentstatus"></div>
3914 <div id="comment_57267042" class="cw">
3915 <div id="comment_top_57267042" class="commentTop newcomment">
3917 <h4><a id="comment_link_57267042" name="comment_link_57267042" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57267042" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57267042)" >how do you see non-existent things ?</a>
3920 <span id="comment_score_57267042" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57267042); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>2</a>)</span></h4>
3922 <div class="details">
3923 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~bingoUV">bingoUV</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~bingoUV">( 1066850 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3924 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57267042"></span>
3927 <div class="commentBody">
3928 <div id="comment_body_57267042"><p>If Consumer AI doesn't have a future, how can that non-existent future be seen ?</p><p>In an alternative interpretation, the author has seen the future of Consumer AI and so of course it exists. But the future of the future of Consumer AI doesn't exist. I.e. Future of Consumer AI doesn't have one - where "one" stands for future.</p><p>Any other interpretations ?</p></div>
3931 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57267042">
3936 <div id="replyto_57267042"></div>
3938 <ul id="group_57267042">
3939 <li id="hiddens_57267042" class="hide"></li>
3942 </li><li id="tree_57267570" class="comment oneline"><span class="ind"></span>
3943 <div id="comment_status_57267570" class="commentstatus"></div>
3944 <div id="comment_57267570" class="cw">
3945 <div id="comment_top_57267570" class="commentTop newcomment">
3947 <h4><a id="comment_link_57267570" name="comment_link_57267570" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&cid=57267570" onclick="return D2.setFocusComment(57267570)" >It's not "Consumer AI"</a>
3950 <span id="comment_score_57267570" class="score"> (<a href="#" onclick="getModalPrefs('modcommentlog', 'Moderation Comment Log', 57267570); return false"><span class=opt>Score:</span>1</a>)</span></h4>
3952 <div class="details">
3953 <span class="by"><span class="byby">by </span><a href="//slashdot.org/~themusicgod1">themusicgod1</a> <span class="uid"><a href="//slashdot.org/~themusicgod1">( 241799 )</a></span></a></span><span class="writes" style="display:none"> writes:</span>
3954 <span class="otherdetails" id="comment_otherdetails_57267570"></span>
3957 <div class="commentBody">
3958 <div id="comment_body_57267570">Since the consumer is not control of it.
3960 It's Anti-Consumer AI if anything</div>
3963 <div class="commentSub" id="comment_sub_57267570">
3968 <div id="replyto_57267570"></div>
3970 <ul id="group_57267570">
3971 <li id="hiddens_57267570" class="hide"></li>
3974 </li><li id="hidestring_0"><noscript><b class='more'><span class="ind"></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&threshold=-1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=0">11 replies</a> beneath your current threshold.</b></noscript></li>
3975 <li id="roothiddens" class="hide"></li>
3982 <noscript><p><b>There may be more comments in this discussion. Without JavaScript enabled, you might want to <a href="//tech.slashdot.org/users.pl?op=editcomm">turn on Classic Discussion System</a> in your preferences instead.</b></p></noscript>
3983 <div id="discussion_buttons" class="clearfix">
3993 <div class="newcmnt"><div id="replyto_0"></div></div>
3996 <script type="text/javascript">
3998 D2.currents()['hidden'] = 36;
3999 D2.currents()['full'] = 8;
4000 D2.currents()['oneline'] = 53;
4001 // D2.currents_total(97);
4003 D2.abbrev_comments({57267112:752,57266410:528,57267434:844,57267056:3,57266506:523,57267462:515,57266126:476,57266022:521});
4004 D2.noshow_comments([57265886,57265890,57265952,57266182,57266348,57266662,57267522,57267508,57266226,57266382,57265938,57265944,57266268,57266392,57266044,57266282,57266042,57266298,57266460,57266490,57267236,57265984,57266016,57266138,57266434,57266756,57267662,57267706,57266066,57266526,57266376,57266402,57266370,57266426,57266782,57266928]);
4005 D2.pieces_comments([57266056,57266716,57267214,57266236,57266566,57267460,57267478,57265994,57266022,57266692,57266126,57266458,57267434,57267440,57266188,57266582,57266132,57266238,57266390,57266462,57267442,57267462,57266100,57266374,57265970,57265996,57266706,57266386,57266030,57266410,57266524,57267474,57267112,57266506,57267056,57267132,57267632,57266104,57266136,57266222,57267484,57266808,57266150,57266220,57267490,57266214,57266712,57267392,57266562,57266590,57266670,57267042,57267570]);
4006 D2.init_hiddens([57265988,57265994,57266126,57265934,57266268,57266100,57266044,57265956,57265996,57266016,57267132,57266038,57266136,57266220,57266150,0]);
4011 if (D2.thresh_totals()[6][6][1] == 0) {
4026 <div id="clickgen" class="grid_24 b">
4027 <section class="grid_16 f">
4030 <a href="" class="selected btmrel" onClick="getRelatedStoriesForStory(345542);return false">Related Links</a>
4031 <span class="tops fright">Top of the: <a href="" class="btmday" onClick="getTopStories(1);return false">day</a>, <a class="btmweek" href="" onClick="getTopStories(7); return false">week</a>, <a href="" onClick="getTopStories(30);return false" class="btmmonth">month</a>.</span>
4033 <ul class="nobullets bmrelatedlist">
4038 <span class="cmntcnt"><span class="slant"></span><span>1175<span class="hide"> comments</span></span></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/story/18/01/08/1954203/james-damore-sues-google-for-allegedly-discriminating-against-conservative-white-men?sdsrc=popbyskidbtmprev">James Damore Sues Google For Allegedly Discriminating Against Conservative White Men</a>
4043 <span class="cmntcnt"><span class="slant"></span><span>953<span class="hide"> comments</span></span></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/story/18/03/19/1736231/self-driving-uber-car-kills-arizona-woman-in-first-fatal-crash-involving-pedestrian?sdsrc=popbyskidbtmprev">Self-Driving Uber Car Kills Arizona Woman in First Fatal Crash Involving Pedestrian</a>
4048 <span class="cmntcnt"><span class="slant"></span><span>707<span class="hide"> comments</span></span></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/story/17/11/16/0050243/twitter-bans-removes-verified-status-of-white-supremacists?sdsrc=popbyskidbtmprev">Twitter Bans, Removes Verified Status of White Supremacists</a>
4053 <span class="cmntcnt"><span class="slant"></span><span>705<span class="hide"> comments</span></span></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/story/18/02/15/2255242/pro-gun-russian-bots-flood-twitter-after-parkland-shooting?sdsrc=popbyskidbtmprev">Pro-Gun Russian Bots Flood Twitter After Parkland Shooting</a>
4058 <span class="cmntcnt"><span class="slant"></span><span>682<span class="hide"> comments</span></span></span><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/story/17/11/19/043243/i-see-things-differently-james-damore-on-his-autism-and-the-google-memo?sdsrc=popbyskidbtmprev">'I See Things Differently': James Damore on his Autism and the Google Memo</a>
4065 <aside class="grid_8 st">
4066 <section class="grid_24 f">
4068 <h5 class="tlnav"><a href="//news.slashdot.org/story/18/09/06/1558206/computer-chips-are-still-made-in-usa?sdsrc=nextbtmnext">next</a></h5>
4069 <div class="grid_24">
4072 <span class="grid_7 tcenter"><img src="//a.fsdn.com/sd/topics/usa_64.png" width="64" height="64" alt="United States"></span>
4074 <p class="grid_12"><a href="//news.slashdot.org/story/18/09/06/1558206/computer-chips-are-still-made-in-usa?sdsrc=nextbtmprev">Computer Chips Are Still 'Made in USA'</a></p>
4075 <span class="grid_5 tcenter comments"><span class="cmntcnt_large fleft"><span class="slant"></span><span>71<span class="hide"> comments</span></span></span></span>
4080 <section class="grid_24">
4082 <h5 class="tlnav"><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/story/18/09/06/1954253/400000-websites-vulnerable-through-exposed-git-directories?sdsrc=prevbtmprev">previous</a></h5>
4083 <div class="grid_24">
4085 <span class="grid_7 tcenter"><img src="//a.fsdn.com/sd/topics/security_64.png" width="64" height="64" alt="Security"></span>
4087 <p class="grid_12"><a href="//tech.slashdot.org/story/18/09/06/1954253/400000-websites-vulnerable-through-exposed-git-directories?sdsrc=prevbtmprev">400,000 Websites Vulnerable Through Exposed<nobr> <wbr></nobr>.git Directories</a></p>
4089 <span class="grid_5 tcenter comments"><span class="cmntcnt_large fleft"><span class="slant"></span><span>32<span class="hide"> comments</span></span></span></span>
4095 <div id="taboola-below-article-text-links"></div>
4096 <script type="text/javascript">
4097 window._taboola = window._taboola || [];
4099 mode: 'text-links-a',
4100 container: 'taboola-below-article-text-links',
4101 placement: 'Below Article Text Links',
4110 <div class="row top-space">
4113 <div class="grid_24">
4116 <div class="adwrap">
4117 <div id='div-gpt-ad-728x90_c'><script type='text/javascript'>
4118 googletag.cmd.push(function(){
4119 googletag.display('div-gpt-ad-728x90_c');});</script></div>
4121 <!-- end 728px ad -->
4122 <!-- Slashdot Deals 6 Best Sellers -->
4123 <div class="row deals-footer">
4124 <div class="units-8 indent-2 deals-wrapper">
4125 <div class="deals-header"><h1>Slashdot Top Deals</h1></div>
4126 <div id="deals-output">
4127 <script id="deals-template" type="text/x-handlebars-template">
4130 <a href="{{urlPath permalink}}?&utm_source=slashdot.org&utm_medium=dealfeed-footerfeed&utm_campaign={{slug}}" target="_blank">
4131 <img src="{{main_image}}" alt="" />
4133 <p class="title"><a href="{{urlPath permalink}}?&utm_source=slashdot.org&utm_medium=dealfeed-footerfeed&utm_campaign={{slug}}" target="_blank">{{title}}</a></p>
4134 <p class="deal-price">{{centConversion price_in_cents}}</p>
4142 if ( isAdBlockActive ) {
4143 $.getScript( "//a.fsdn.com/sd/js/scripts/min/deals-min.js", function(){
4149 <!-- End Slashdot Deals 6 Best Sellers -->
4154 <!-- SMACKS: END COMMENTS SECTION -->
4156 <!-- SMACKS: END COMMENTS CONTAINER -->
4161 <script type="text/javascript">
4164 $('#firehose-filter').
4165 focus(function(event){
4166 gFocusedText = this;
4168 blur(function(event){
4169 if ( gFocusedText === this ) {
4170 gFocusedText = null;
4175 apply_updates_when( 'at-end', true);
4180 <!-- body end --><!-- footer type=current begin -->
4187 <footer id="fhft" class="grid_24 nf aoc">
4188 <div id="logo_nf" class="fleft">
4189 <a href="//slashdot.org"><span>Slashdot</span></a>
4191 <nav role="firehose footer">
4199 <span class="ind"></span><a class="btn first" href="//tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=12580424&op=reply&threshold=1&commentsort=0&mode=thread&pid=" onclick="D2.replyTo(0); return false;">Post</a>
4201 <a class="btn hide" id="footer_moderate_button">Moderate</a>
4202 <a class="btn hide" id="footer_moderatorhelp_button">Moderator Help</a>
4203 <a class="btn hide" id="footer_delete_button" title="Checked comments will be deleted.">Delete</a>
4206 var old_moderate_btn = $("#discussion_moderate_button");
4207 if (old_moderate_btn.length) {
4208 var moderate_btn = $("#footer_moderate_button");
4210 function(){old_moderate_btn.click()}
4212 moderate_btn.removeClass('hide');
4215 var old_moderatorhelp_btn = $("#discussion_moderatorhelp_button");
4216 if (old_moderatorhelp_btn.length) {
4217 var moderatorhelp_btn = $("#footer_moderatorhelp_button");
4218 moderatorhelp_btn.click(
4219 function(){old_moderatorhelp_btn.click()}
4221 moderatorhelp_btn.attr(
4222 'href', old_moderatorhelp_btn.attr('href')
4224 moderatorhelp_btn.removeClass('hide');
4227 var old_delete_btn = $("#discussion_delete_button");
4228 if (old_delete_btn.length) {
4229 var delete_btn = $("#footer_delete_button");
4231 function(){old_delete_btn.click()}
4233 delete_btn.removeClass('hide');
4236 $('#discussion_buttons').addClass('hide');
4237 })(Slash.jQuery); // (function($){
4241 <li class="fleft selected">
4242 <span class="nbutton btn hide link reset" id="more_comments_button">
4243 <a href="#" onclick="D2.ajaxFetchComments(0,1); return false">
4244 <span id="more_comments_num_a" class="hide">Get more comments</span>
4251 <span class="loadedcommentcnt">97</span> of <span class="totalcommentcnt">97</span> loaded
4256 <script type="text/javascript">D2.finishLoading()</script>
4261 <ul class="fright submitstory">
4263 <a href="/submit">Submit<span class="opt"> Story</span></a>
4271 <section class="bq">
4272 <blockquote class="msg grid_24" cite="https://slashdot.org">
4273 <p>The hardest part of climbing the ladder of success is getting through
4274 the crowd at the bottom.</p>
4275 <span class="slant"></span>
4278 <footer id="ft" class="grid_24">
4279 <nav class="grid_10" role="footer">
4281 <li><a href="//slashdot.org/faq">FAQ</a></li>
4282 <li><a href="//slashdot.org/archive.pl">Story Archive</a></li>
4283 <li><a href="//slashdot.org/hof.shtml">Hall of Fame</a></li>
4284 <li><a href="http://slashdotmedia.com/advertising-and-marketing-services/">Advertising</a></li>
4285 <li><a href="http://slashdotmedia.com/terms-of-use/">Terms</a></li>
4286 <li><a href="http://slashdotmedia.com/privacy-statement/">Privacy Statement</a></li>
4287 <li id='eu_privacy' style='display:none'><a href="#" title="Privacy Choices" onclick="bizx.cmp.promptConsent();return false;">Privacy Choices</a></li>
4288 <li><a href="http://slashdotmedia.com/opt-out-choices/">Opt-out Choices</a></li>
4289 <li><a href="//slashdot.org/faq/slashmeta.shtml">About</a></li>
4290 <li><a href="mailto:feedback@slashdot.org">Feedback</a></li>
4291 <li><a href="#" onclick="set_mobile_pref('mobile',1);return false;">Mobile View</a></li>
4292 <li><a href="//slashdot.org/blog">Blog</a></li>
4296 if (window.is_euro_union) {
4297 document.getElementById('eu_privacy').style.display = 'inline';
4302 <div class="grid_14 tright tm">Trademarks property of their respective owners. Comments owned by the poster. <span class="nobr">Copyright © 2018 SlashdotMedia. All Rights Reserved.</span></div>
4306 <div class="overlay"></div>
4307 <div class="modal-box">
4308 <a href="#" id="close-modal">Close</a>
4309 <article class="modal-content">
4317 <div id="modal_cover" class="hide" onclick="hide_modal_box(); return false;"></div>
4318 <div id="modal_box" class="hide">
4319 <div id="modal_box_content"></div>
4321 <span class="fadeout"></span>
4322 <span class="fadeoutfade"></span>
4323 <span class="pf"><a class="ico close" onclick="hide_modal_box(); return false;" href="#"><span>Close</span></a></span>
4324 <h3 class="pf"><div id="logo"><a href="//slashdot.org">Slashdot</a></div><span id="preference_title"></span></h3>
4329 <script type="text/javascript">
4330 if (!window.is_euro_union) {
4332 /*global _ml:true, window */
4333 _ml = window._ml || {};
4336 var s = document.getElementsByTagName('script')[0], cd = new Date(), mltag = document.createElement('script');
4337 mltag.type = 'text/javascript'; mltag.async = true;
4338 mltag.src = '//ml314.com/tag.aspx?' + cd.getDate() + cd.getMonth() + cd.getFullYear();
4339 s.parentNode.insertBefore(mltag, s);
4343 <!-- End CCM Tag -->
4345 <script type="text/javascript">
4346 window.google_analytics_uacct = "UA-32013-5";
4348 var _gaq = _gaq || [];
4354 _gaq.push(['_setAccount', 'UA-36136016-1']);
4355 _gaq.push(['b._setAccount', 'UA-32013-5']);
4356 _gaq.push(['_setDomainName', '.slashdot.org']);
4357 _gaq.push(['b._setDomainName', '.slashdot.org']);
4360 _gaq.push(['_addIgnoredRef', 'slashdot.org']);
4361 _gaq.push(['b._addIgnoredRef', 'slashdot.org']);
4365 _gaq.push(['_setCustomVar', 1, 'User Type', 'Anon', 3]);
4366 _gaq.push(['b._setCustomVar', 1, 'User Type', 'Anon', 3]);
4368 _gaq.push(['_setCustomVar', 2, 'Page','article2', 3]);
4369 _gaq.push(['b._setCustomVar', 2, 'Page','article2', 3]);
4375 // track beta behavior for user
4376 var betamatches = document.cookie.match(/betagroup=(-?\d+)/);
4378 if(betamatches && betamatches[1]) {
4379 if(betamatches[1] == -1) {
4380 _gaq.push(['_setCustomVar', 3, 'Beta-Usage','opt-out', 3]);
4382 _gaq.push(['_setCustomVar', 3, 'Beta-Usage','unredirected', 3]);
4388 _gaq.push(['_trackPageview']);
4389 _gaq.push(['b._trackPageview']);
4390 _gaq.push(['_trackPageLoadTime']);
4391 _gaq.push(['b._trackPageLoadTime']);
4394 if (!window.is_euro_union) {
4396 var ga = document.createElement('script'); ga.type = 'text/javascript'; ga.async = true;
4397 ga.src = ('https:' == document.location.protocol ? 'https://ssl' : 'http://www') + '.google-analytics.com/ga.js';
4398 var s = document.getElementsByTagName('script')[0]; s.parentNode.insertBefore(ga, s);
4403 <!-- CCM GA Push -->
4405 if (typeof _ml !== 'undefined' && _ml.us) {
4406 if (_ml.us.tp && _ml.us.tp.length > 0) {
4407 ga('set', 'dimension2', _ml.us.tp[0]);
4409 if (_ml.us.pc && _ml.us.pc.length > 0) {
4410 ga('set', 'dimension7', _ml.us.pc[0]);
4412 ga('set', 'dimension3', _ml.us.ind);
4413 ga('set', 'dimension4', _ml.us.cr);
4414 ga('set', 'dimension5', _ml.us.cs);
4415 ga('set', 'dimension6', _ml.us.dm);
4416 ga('set', 'dimension8', _ml.us.sn);
4421 <script type="text/javascript">
4422 var topBannerViewed = false;
4423 if($('#div-gpt-ad-728x90_a').length > 0 && window.outerWidth >= 1070 && !isAdBlockActive){
4424 $(window).scroll(function(){
4425 var y = $(document).scrollTop();
4426 var z = y + window.outerHeight;
4429 $('.nav-wrap').outerHeight(true),
4430 $('.nav-secondary-wrap').outerHeight(true)
4433 if(offset[row]) navOffset = navOffset + parseInt(offset[row]);
4435 $('.adwrap-unviewed').each(function(){
4436 var cls = 'adwrap-sticky';
4437 var toggleCls = 'adwrap';
4438 //$('.banner-wrapper').css('height', $('.banner-contain').outerHeight());
4439 if($(this).hasClass('railad')) {
4440 if(topBannerViewed){
4441 var topPixels = $(this).offset().top;
4442 navOffset += $('.adwrap').outerHeight();
4443 if(y >= topPixels && y >= navOffset){
4444 $('#slashboxes').css('top', 0).css('position','fixed').css('right',13);
4446 $('#slashboxes').removeAttr('style');
4451 var topPixels = $(this).offset().top;
4452 if(y >= topPixels && y >= navOffset){
4453 $(this).addClass(cls);
4454 $(this).removeClass('adwrap');
4455 if(cls == 'adwrap-sticky') { //top banner
4456 topBannerViewed = false;
4457 $('#slashboxes').css('top',$(this).outerHeight() || 0).css('position','fixed').css('right',13);
4459 if(topBannerViewed) {
4460 console.log('hereeee');
4461 $('#slashboxes').css('top', 0).css('position','fixed').css('right',13);
4464 $(this).removeClass(cls);
4465 $(this).addClass(toggleCls);
4466 $('#slashboxes').removeAttr('style');
4469 if($('.adwrap-viewed-banner').length > 0){
4470 topBannerViewed = true;
4471 $('.adwrap-viewed-banner').removeClass('adwrap-unviewed').removeClass('adwrap-sticky').addClass('adwrap');
4473 if($('.adwrap-viewed-railad').length > 0){
4474 $('.adwrap-viewed-railad').removeClass('adwrap-unviewed').removeClass('adwrap-railad-sticky');
4475 $('#slashboxes').removeAttr('style');
4482 <script type="text/javascript">
4483 var _paq = _paq || [];
4484 _paq.push(["setCookieDomain", "*.slashdot.org"]);
4485 _paq.push(['trackPageView']);
4486 _paq.push(['enableLinkTracking']);
4487 function initPiwikAndNels() {
4489 var u="//analytics.slashdotmedia.com/";
4490 _paq.push(['setTrackerUrl', u+'sd.php']);
4491 _paq.push(['setSiteId', 40]);
4492 var d=document, g=d.createElement('script'), s=d.getElementsByTagName('script')[0];
4493 g.type='text/javascript'; g.async=true; g.defer=true; g.src=u+'sd.js'; s.parentNode.insertBefore(g,s);
4496 if(window.location.pathname == '/'){
4497 var nelId = (location.search.split('nel_id=')[1] || '').split('&')[0];
4498 var url = '/ajax.pl?op=nel';
4500 url += '&nel_id='+nelId;
4504 success: function(html){
4505 $('#firehoselist article').eq(1).after(html);
4510 if(document.getElementById('announcementText')){
4511 $('#announcementText').hide();
4512 var hlUrl = '/ajax.pl?op=hl_nel';
4514 hlUrl += '&nel_id='+nelId;
4518 success: function(html){
4519 if(html.length < 10){
4520 $('#announcementText').show();
4523 $('#announcementText').html(html).show();
4525 error: function () {
4526 $('#announcementText').show();
4531 bizx.cmp.ifConsent('publisher', ['storage', 'measurement'], initPiwikAndNels);
4535 <script type="text/javascript">
4536 _linkedin_data_partner_id = "113712";
4537 </script><script type="text/javascript">
4538 if (!window.is_euro_union) {
4539 (function(){var s = document.getElementsByTagName("script")[0];
4540 var b = document.createElement("script");
4541 b.type = "text/javascript";b.async = true;
4542 b.src = "https://snap.licdn.com/li.lms-analytics/insight.min.js";
4543 s.parentNode.insertBefore(b, s);})();
4547 <img height="1" width="1" style="display:none;" alt="" src="https://dc.ads.linkedin.com/collect/?pid=113712&fmt=gif" />
4551 <script async type="text/javascript" src="//ads.pro-market.net/ads/scripts/site-143573.js"></script>
4552 <script id="after-content" type="text/javascript">
4553 (function( $, fn, console ){
4554 $ && fn && $(function(){ fn($, console); });
4555 })(window.jQuery, window.pageload_done, window.console);
4557 <img src="//slashdot.org/adbanner.gif?t=20180907" alt="">
4558 <img src="//slashdot.org/purple.gif?t=20180907" alt="">
4559 <script type='text/javascript'>
4560 if(!document.location.href.match(/source=autorefresh/)) {
4561 document.write('<img src="//slashdot.org/images/js.gif?315">');
4565 <img src="//slashdot.org/images/njs.gif?378">
4567 <div class="busy genericspinner hide"><span>Working...</span></div>
4569 if(typeof(Storage)!=="undefined"){
4570 window.scrollTo(0,sessionStorage.scrollPos);
4571 $(window).scroll(function () {
4572 //You've scrolled this much:
4573 sessionStorage.scrollPos = $(window).scrollTop();
4577 $('a').click(function(){
4578 delete sessionStorage.scrollPos;
4581 // window.onbeforeunload = function () {
4582 // console.log('bakc button clicked');
4583 // delete sessionStorage.scrollPos;
4585 window.onpopstate=function() {
4586 delete sessionStorage.scrollPos;
4592 <!-- 1x1 story page -->
4593 <div id='div-gpt-ad-1x1'><script type='text/javascript'>
4594 googletag.cmd.push(function(){
4595 googletag.display('div-gpt-ad-1x1');});</script></div>
4598 <script type="text/javascript">
4599 if (!window.is_euro_union) {
4600 window._taboola = window._taboola || [];
4601 _taboola.push({flush: true});
4609 <!-- footer type=current end -->